Highlights

 
Quotable
O, it is excellent To have a giant’s strength! But it is tyrannous To use it like a giant.
William Shakespeare
Original Letters Blog US Casualties Contact Donate

 
August 8, 2006

The End of Illusions

by Jonathan Cook

If there were any remaining illusions about the purpose of Israel's war against Lebanon, the draft United Nations Security Council resolution calling for a "cessation of major hostilities" published over the weekend should finally dispel them. This entirely one-sided document was drafted, noted the Hebrew-language media, with close Israeli involvement. The top adviser to Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert talked through the resolution with the U.S. and French teams, while the Israeli Foreign Ministry had its man alongside John Bolton at the UN building in New York.

The only thing preventing Israeli officials from jumping up and down with glee, according to Aluf Benn of the daily Ha'aretz newspaper, was the fear that "demonstrated Israeli enthusiasm for the draft could influence support among Security Council members, who could demand a change in wording that may adversely affect Israel." So no celebration parties till the resolution is passed.

Instead, in a cynical ploy familiar from previous negotiating processes, Israel submitted to the U.S. a list of requests for amendments to the resolution. When Israel agrees to forgo these amendments, it will, of course, be able to take credit for its flexibility and desire to compromise; Lebanon and Hezbollah, on the other hand, will be cast as villains, rejecting international peacemaking efforts.

The reason for Israel's barely concealed pleasure is that Hezbollah now faces an international diplomatic and public relations assault in place of the unsuccessful Israeli military one. Israel and the United States are trying to set a series of traps for Hezbollah – and Lebanon too – that will justify Israel's reoccupation of south Lebanon, the further ethnic cleansing of the country, and a widening of the war to include Iran, and possibly Syria.

The clues were not hard to decode. U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice characterized the aim of the resolution as clarifying who is acting in good faith. "We're going to know who really did want to stop the violence and who didn't," she said. Or, in other words, we are going to be able to blame Hezbollah for the hostilities, because we have offered them terms of surrender we know they will never agree to.

The main sticking point for Hezbollah is to be found in the resolution's requirement that it must stop fighting and begin a process of disarmament at a time when Israeli forces are still occupying Lebanese territory and when there may be a lengthy, if not interminable, wait for their replacement by international peacekeepers. Not only that, but the resolution allows Israel to continue its military operations for defensive purposes: Hezbollah only has to look to Gaza or the West Bank to see what Israel is likely to consider falling under the rubric of "defensive."

Hezbollah has been stockpiling weapons since Israel's withdrawal in May 2000 precisely to create a "balance of deterrence," to make Israel more cautious about sating its demonstrated appetite for occupying its neighbors' lands, particularly when the neighbor is a small country like Lebanon without a proper army and divided into many sectarian groups, some of which, for a price, may be willing to collaborate with Israel.

This time, however, as Israeli troops struggle back toward the Litani River and their initial goal of creating a "buffer zone" similar to the one they held on to for nearly two decades, the Lebanese are rallying behind Hezbollah, convinced that the Shi'ite militia is their only protection against Western machinations for a "new Middle East."

Israel and Washington, however, may hope that, given time, they can break that national solidarity by provoking a civil war in Lebanon to deplete local energies, similar to Israel's attempts at engineering feuds between Hamas and Fatah in the occupied Palestinian territories. Certainly, it is difficult to make sense otherwise of Israel's bombing for the first time of Christian neighborhoods in Beirut and what looks like the intended ethnic cleansing of Sunni Muslims from Sidon, which was leafleted by Israeli war planes over the weekend.

In the U.S.-Israeli view, a nation of refugees living in an open-air prison cut off from the outside world and deprived of food and aid – a more ambitious version of the Gaza model – may eventually be persuaded to take their wrath out on their Shi'ite defenders.

Hezbollah understands that the proposal to bring in a force of international peacekeepers is another trap. Either the foreign troops will never arrive, because on these Israeli-imposed terms there can be no cease-fire, or, if they do arrive, they will quickly become a proxy occupation army. Israel will have its new South Lebanon Army, supplied direct this time from the UN and subsidized by the West. If Hezbollah fights, it will be killing foreign peacekeepers, not Israeli soldiers.

But Israel knows the international force is almost certainly a non-starter, which seems to be the main reason it has now, belatedly, become so enthusiastic about it. Senior Israeli government officials were saying as much in the Hebrew-language media on Sunday.

Israel's justice minister, the increasingly hawkish Haim Ramon, summed up the view from Tel Aviv:

"Even if it is passed, it is doubtful that Hezbollah will honor the resolution and halt its fire. Therefore we have to continue fighting, continue hitting anyone we can hit in Hezbollah, and I assume that as long as that goes on, Israel's standing, diplomatically and militarily, will improve."

Israel hopes it will be able to keep hitting Hezbollah harder – at less cost to its troops and civilians, and with improved diplomatic standing – because in the next phase, after the resolution is passed, the Shi'ite militia will find that one arm has been tied, figuratively speaking, behind its back.

Not only will Washington and Israel blame Hezbollah for refusing to agree to the cease-fire, but they will seek to use any retaliation against Israeli "defensive" aggression – including, presumably, further invasion – as a pretext for widening the war and dragging in the real target of their belligerence: Iran.

This subterfuge was voiced over the weekend by Israel's ambassador to the UN, Dan Gillerman, who told the BBC that if Hezbollah fired at Tel Aviv – which it has threatened to do if Israel continues attacking Beirut – this would be tantamount to an "act of war" that could only have been ordered by Iran. In other words, at some point soon Israel may stop blaming Hezbollah and turn its fire – defensively, of course – on Iran.

This linkage is being carefully prepared by Olmert. On Monday, according to the Hebrew-language press, he told some 50 government spokespeople what message to deliver to the foreign media: "Our enemy is not Hezbollah, but Iran, which employs Hezbollah as its agent." According to Ha'aretz, he urged the spokespeople "not to be ashamed to express emotion and appeal to feelings."

So in the coming days, in the wake of this U.S.-Israeli concoction of an impossible peace, we are going to be hearing a lot more nonsense from Israel and the White House about Iran's role in supposedly initiating and expanding this war, its desire to "wipe Israel off the map," and the nuclear weapons it is developing so that it can achieve its aim.

The capture of two Israeli soldiers on July 12 will be decoupled from Hezbollah's domestic objectives. No one will talk of those soldiers as bargaining chips in the prisoner swap Hezbollah has been demanding; or as an attempt by Hezbollah's leader, Hassan Nasrallah, to deflect U.S.-inspired political pressure on him to disarm his militia and leave Lebanon defenseless to Israel's long-planned invasion; or as a populist show of solidarity by Hezbollah with the oppressed Palestinians of Gaza.

Those real causes of hostilities will be ignored as more, mostly Lebanese, civilians die, and Israel and the U.S. expand the theater of war. Instead, we will hear much of the rockets that are still landing in northern Israel and how they have been supplied by Iran. The fact that Hezbollah attacks followed rather than precipitated Israel's massive bombardment of Lebanon will be forgotten. Rockets fired by Hezbollah to stop Israeli aggression against Lebanon will be retold as an Iranian-inspired war to destroy the Jewish state. The nuclear-armed Goliath of Israel will, once again, be transformed into a plucky little David. Or at least such is the Israeli and American scenario.

 

comments on this article?
 
 
Archives

  • Turkey's Fallout With Israel Deals Blow to Settlers 
    3/26/2009

  • Bedouin Baby's Power Struggle With Israel
    3/19/2009

  • Israel's Military Mephistopheles
    2/27/2009

  • Is Israel's Army Waging a Jewish Jihad?
    2/5/2009

  • Israel Intensified Assault in Final Days
    1/21/2009

  • Israeli Assault Injures 1.5 Million Gazans
    1/17/2009

  • Israeli Arab Parties React to Election Ban
    1/15/2009

  • Blueprint for Gaza Attack Was Long Planned
    1/13/2009

  • Criticism of Israeli War Crimes Mounts
    1/10/2009

  • Israel's Aim: To Make the Gazan Prison Even More Secure
    1/8/2009

  • The Real Goal of the Slaughter in Gaza
    1/2/2009

  • Electioneering With Bombs
    12/31/2008

  • Arab Town Blamed for Jewish Pride March's Cancelation
    12/20/2008

  • Hebron Settlers Take Their Fight Into Israel
    12/6/2008

  • Campaign for 'Forgotten Refugees' Downplays Palestinian Losses
    12/3/2008

  • Who Will Stop the Settlers?
    11/20/2008

  • The Real Goal of Israel's Blockade
    11/18/2008

  • Israel Tightens Chokehold on Village of Entrepreneurs
    11/15/2008

  • Travesty of Tolerance on Display in Jerusalem
    11/6/2008

  • Palestinian Kristallnacht
    10/31/2008

  • Israel Bars Visit to Father's Grave
    10/30/2008

  • Israel's 'City of Coexistence' Shows Its True Colors
    10/17/2008

  • Israeli Bestseller Breaks National Taboo
    10/9/2008

  • Israel's Army and Settlers Fall Out
    10/4/2008

  • Israel's Breeding Ground for Terrorism
    10/1/2008

  • King David Recruited to Expel Palestinians
    9/27/2008

  • Jaffa's 'Renewal' Aims at Expulsion of Palestinians
    9/16/2008

  • Israel's Dark Art of Ensnaring Palestinian Collaborators
    9/13/2008

  • Palestinian Village Faces Army Reign of Terror
    9/3/2008

  • Israel's Outposts Seal Death of Palestinian State
    8/26/2008

  • The Struggle Against Jerusalem's Quiet Ethnic Cleansing
    8/2/2008

  • The Smallest Settlement
    7/28/2008

  • Zionism's Dead End
    6/28/2008

  • On Independence Day, Israeli Arabs Reminded of Their Place
    5/17/2008

  • Two-State Dreamers
    3/13/2008

  • Israel Plots Another Palestinian Exodus
    3/10/2008

  • Academic Freedom? Not for Arabs in Israel
    3/1/2008

  • Evidence of Israeli 'Cowardly Blending' Comes to Light
    1/5/2008

  • Why Did Israel Attack Syria?
    9/28/2007

  • In 2006 Lebanon War, Most Crimes Were Israeli
    8/17/2007

  • Israel's Jewish Problem in Tehran
    8/4/2007

  • Divide and Rule, Israeli-Style
    6/27/2007

  • Olmert Reveals the Real Goal of War in Lebanon
    3/14/2007

  • Apartheid Looks Like This
    2/24/2007

  • Israel's Dark Future
    1/20/2007

  • Israel's Purging of Palestinian Christians
    1/10/2007

  • End of the Strongmen
    12/20/2006

  • The Trap of Recognizing Israel
    12/16/2006

  • Syria: Convenient but Unlikely Fall Guy for Gemayel's Death
    11/24/2006

  • Hollow Visions of Palestine's Future
    11/18/2006

  • The Struggle for Palestine's Soul
    10/7/2006

  • Bad Faith and the Destruction of Palestine
    9/30/2006

  • The 'New Anti-Semitism' and Nuclear War
    9/25/2006

  • How Human Rights Watch Lost Its Way in Lebanon
    9/8/2006

  • Israel's Deceptions
    a Way of Life
    9/1/2006

  • After Lebanon, Israel Looks for More War
    8/21/2006

  • Lebanese Deaths, and Israeli War Crimes, Kept Off the Balance Sheet
    8/17/2006

  • Suddenly, I'm an 'Islamic Fascist'
    8/12/2006

  • Hypocrisy About Hezbollah
    8/10/2006

  • The End of Illusions
    8/8/2006

  • Winning the Propaganda War
    8/4/2006

  • Why Do They Hate Us?
    Listen to Qana (Again)
    8/1/2006

  • The Lies Israel Tells Itself (and We Tell on Its Behalf)
    7/29/2006

  • Five Myths That Sanction Israel's War Crimes
    7/26/2006

  • Israel's Disproportionate Violence No Surprise
    7/22/2006
  • Jonathan Cook is a writer and journalist based in Nazareth, Israel. His most recent book, Israel and the Clash of Civilizations: Iraq, Iran, and the Plan to Remake the Middle East, is published by Pluto Press. Visit his Web site.

    Reproduction of material from any original Antiwar.com pages
    without written permission is strictly prohibited.
    Copyright 2014 Antiwar.com