Orange County's best source for local information Sunday
July 25, 2004
COAST: 80 ° Forecast Ocean
INLAND: 88 ° Traffic Surf
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
CUSTOMER SERVICE
OCRegister.com OC Car Finder OC Job Finder OC Real Estate Finder myoc.com OCVive.com
Browse past 7 days
Advanced search
Classifieds
Car | Job | Home | More
> Place an ad
Marketplace
 • Newspaper ads
 • Coupons
 • Buy our photos
Sections
 E-REGISTER
 The print edition online
 E-REGISTER ARCHIVE
 E-COMMUNITIES
 Weekly newspapers
TODAY'S FRONT PAGE
 HOME PAGE
 REGISTER TOP NEWS
 AT WORK EXTRA
 BUSINESS
 COLUMNS
 COMMENTARY
 EDUCATION
 ENTERTAINMENT
 FOOD & WINE
 HEALTH & FAMILY
 HOME & GARDEN
 INVESTIGATIONS
 LIFE, ETC.
 LOCAL
 MULTIMEDIA
 NATION & WORLD
 OBITUARIES
 REGION & STATE
 SPECIAL FEATURES
 SPORTS
 TRAVEL
 WEATHER
Community news
Noticias en Espaņol
Interactive tools
Discussion boards
Financial tools
Get a map
Get directions
Make this my
home page
Movie times
Place a classified ad
Puzzles & games
Traffic
Yellow pages
Information
About us
Advertise with us
Contact us
Customer service
Register in education
Site feedback
Subscribe today
Media partners
MSNBC
OCExcelsior.com
myOC.com
KPCC
KOCE
COMMENTARY

Sunday, July 25, 2004

The Army's whitewash


On the same day the 9/11 Commission released its long-anticipated report, another government commission quietly released the results of its study. Whereas the 9/11 report is widely praised for its openness and fairness, the U.S. Army's investigation of military treatment of detainees in Iraq and Afghanistan appears to be a whitewash.

Critics rightly questioned whether the Army report was released the same day as the 9/11 commission report so it wouldn't get the careful media attention it deserved. The Army investigation concluded the abuse of prisoners was an aberration and that the blame was squarely on the shoulders of the few soldiers who engaged in the abuse. In his testimony on Capitol Hill, Lt. Gen. Paul Mikolashek defended the military and downplayed any abuse.

Even the numbers the Army released were downplayed to minimize the problems. For instance, the report pointed to 94 cases of abuse, counting the entire Abu Ghraib scandal as one abuse. That's ridiculous. The Army's conclusions contrast with conclusions made by Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba, who pointed to systemic problems, and not just to "unauthorized actions taken by a few individuals."

During a heated exchange on Capitol Hill on Thursday, senators pointed to a report by the International Committee of the Red Cross that also found the problems to be systemic, according to the New York Times. Several senators, including Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., actively disputed accounts in the Army's new report.

It's far too self-serving for the Army to blame Abu Ghraib and many other instances of abuse on a handful of bad actors at the lowest-possible levels. Once the smoke of the 9/11 Commission clears, Congress needs to do its job and look more closely at the problem.

Copyright 2004 The Orange County Register | Privacy policy | User agreement
Freedom communications Freedom Communications, Inc.