Sunday, September 11, 2005
Back to ground zero
Katrina forces us to confront
the question: Have we learned nothing from the terrorist
attacks of four years ago?
Four years later Hurricane Katrina has provided some
unwelcome context within which to view the World Trade Center
and Pentagon terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001.
Today, more Americans seem inclined to draw what seems to
some of us the inescapable conclusion of both disasters: Both
9/11 and Katrina represent enormous failures by the federal
government to provide the one thing most Americans think
government actually ought to do: protect the people from
threats foreign, domestic and natural.
But in the months after 9/11, most Americans had seemed to
learn the lesson the government wanted to teach: The failure
of the government to prevent the attacks proved that
government needed to be even bigger and more powerful,
possessed of more powers to deploy - hopefully against
terrorists and other genuine threats, but against the American
people if they got too uppity - in the never-ending quest for
perfect safety. So we got the Transportation Security
Administration confiscating fingernail clippers at airports
and the Patriot Act authorizing snooping into people's reading
habits at libraries - and being deployed against a strip club
owner in Las Vegas dabbling in minor municipal graft.
We got the behemoth Homeland Security Administration,
cobbled together from existing agencies, all of which needed
reform but were pretty much guaranteed immunity from
skepticism now that they had become fashionable. The president
saw his approval in the polls, which had been languishing
after a lackadaisical first summer in office, shoot up to 90
percent in the Sept. 21-22 Gallup Poll. To keep those ratings
high we saw him not only declare "war on terrorism" but try to
buy votes the old-fashioned way: with a prescription drug
benefit for Medicare recipients, the No Child Left Behind
education act that increased the grip of the federal
government over the nation's schools, and increased domestic
spending.
And we got the war in Iraq, which, when all the prewar
justifications melted into nothingness, was rhetorically
transformed into a new war to make the world safe for
democracy. Few paid attention to the few among us who noted
that having U.S. troops stationed all over the world, often
meddling in local politics, was a provocation to terrorists,
even though a Pentagon study had shown that terrorist
incidents directed against United States interests and friends
always increased in areas where the U.S. was actively engaged.
Few took seriously the contention - despite significant
evidence - that the U.S. intelligence "community" failed to
connect the dots prior to 9/11 not because it was underfunded
and underresourced, but because it was too big, too bloated
and too full of people more interested in bureaucratic games
and turf battles than in protecting the American people.
So we turned it all into Homeland Security and invested
countless billions, in the hope that next time disaster or
terrorists struck, the federal government would be ready,
possessed of a coherent plan and ready to spring into action
to save lives and ease suffering. Then came Katrina. And it
turned out that the empire had no clothes.
The death toll for the hurricane is not in yet, and it
could turn out to be lower than the tens of thousands some
officials are predicting. But estimates of the cost to
taxpayers, just at the level of the national government, for
rescue, repair, temporary housing and rebuilding are now
approaching $100 billion, or about five times the $21 billion
the feds allocated to New York City after the 9/11
attacks.
The formalities of declaring a federal emergency were
finished Saturday, Aug. 27. As the hurricane approached the
Gulf Coast, it was upgraded to a Category 4 and then, briefly,
a Category 5. According to Dr. Max Mayfield, director of the
National Hurricane Center, President Bush and FEMA Director
Michael Brown were briefed on the likelihood the New Orleans
levees would be breached and the city flooded. Mayor Ray Nagin
ordered a mandatory evacuation Monday morning but didn't
mobilize school buses and municipal buses to carry it out.
On Monday morning Katrina made landfall and water started
to flow over the levees almost immediately. President Bush
went to an Arizona resort and a California senior center to
promote his Medicare benefit. At 11:30 a.m. FEMA director
Brown requested that Homeland Security dispatch 1,000 people
to New Orleans; his memo gave them two days to arrive.
The long and short of it was that the federal government's
emergency management capability, after all that beefing up,
was a muscle-bound behemoth that couldn't move without 17
signatures in triplicate and had no sense of mission or
urgency.
As late as Wednesday night on CNN, Brown was claiming, "I
must say, this storm is much bigger than anyone expected,"
after at least a week of cable-news hype about how much bigger
Katrina was than previous storms. Perhaps federal officials
should be congratulated for ignoring most of what appears on
cable news. But for ignoring what their own officials told
them?
After the terrorist attacks administration officials often
repeated the mantra, "9/11 changed everything." (As with so
much leading to the Iraq war and beyond, it was Vice President
Dick Cheney who actually used the phrase repeatedly, to
justify military operations and incursions on civil
liberties).
Yes, the terrorist attacks did change a lot. They drove
home the lesson that there are Islamist jihadists out there
who not only hate the United States but had the capability of
carrying out a devastating attack on American soil. They gave
the government license to attack Afghanistan, detain about a
thousand Muslims without charges or lawyers for months, and
later to opt out of international agreements on the treatment
of prisoners.
But those attacks did not mark an end of American innocence
or a watershed change in American attitudes. The president
told us to be vigilant and shop 'til we dropped, the
government would handle things. There was an inspiring
outburst of volunteerism and fellow-feeling, not only in
America but around the world. But before long most Americans -
and most decidedly most politicians - returned to the usual
habits of thinking first about Number One. And the government
commenced squandering the tide of sympathy that the attacks
engendered.
Unfortunately, those who became most influential in
affecting U.S. policy - people who had been hoping for a way
to take Saddam Hussein down since the first gulf war - did not
maintain a laser-like focus on the actual threat.
Faced with a stateless terrorist organization that used the
Internet and other technology to coordinate a dispersed and
decentralized organization, they insisted on doing what a
country with an effective military would prefer to do rather
than deal with a novel threat that's difficult to identify and
penetrate. They identified a state to attack in a military
way, then hyped that third-rate dictatorship that posed no
immediate threat to any of its neighbors into an imminent
threat to the most powerful nation the world had ever
known.
Four years later, Osama bin Laden is still at large.
Terrorist attacks around the world have increased, not
decreased. The United States military is overstretched and
ill-used in an occupation in a largely hostile country - or at
least with enough hostiles to create chaos - in which several
Americans a day are killed and the insurgency keeps growing.
Military morale and recruitment are on the verge of serious
trouble. Anti-Americanism has increased exponentially.
We haven't begun to learn - we haven't begun to think about
- the lesson that government hyperactivity overseas creates
more enemies than friends. We haven't learned that bigger
government is not better government and more often than not is
uncoordinated and incompetent in spectacular ways. We haven't
learned that the state as an institution, rooted in and
depending on force as it is, cannot generate compassion,
wisdom or protection, that intelligent people eventually learn
to depend on themselves and their neighbors rather than
bureaucracies by the Potomac.
Perhaps Katrina will help Americans to begin to think about
these issues more clearly.
CONTACT US: abock@ocregister.com or
(714) 796-7821
|