"Laughs" And "Chuckles"
in State Department Transcripts:

Where Did the KLA Get Its Weapons From?
by
Michel Chossudovsky
July 27, 2001

Official transcripts of US State Department briefings reproduce "verbatim" the "questions" (Q) by journalists and the answers of the State Department spokesperson. Words are always transcribed phonetically, "Yes" is recorded as "yeah", grammatical and speech errors are also recorded, non-verbal "noises" such as "laughs," "chuckles," "applause" as well as "mm-hmm," "wow" and "huh" are also transcribed.

"Laughs" and "chuckles" are usually associated with a Question (Q) from an individual journalist or an answer by the State Department official, whereas "laughter" is from the floor. The "chuckles" and "laughs" often come after an embarrassing question, or when the State Department spokesperson says "Yeah, I don't know" or "I don't want to get into that." "Chuckles" is often a way of skirting the question. It also means, "You know the answer, why are you asking…"

A few months before the onslaught of the NATO bombings of Yugoslavia, the State Department held a "Special Briefing" on Kosovo (November 1998). James Pardew, Washington's "mediator" now in charge of "disarming" NLA-KLA terrorists in Macedonia, had been appointed in 1998 "Special Representative for Kosovo Implementation" by the Clinton Adminstration. Joined by Julia Taft, Assistant Secretary of State for Population, Refugees and Migration, Pardew answers questions on a central issue of the Kosovar crisis:

Q: Where are the arms coming from? I mean, the Yugoslav forces' arms are coming from Yugoslavia. Where is the KLA getting their arms?

MR. PARDEW: I can't answer that. I don't know the answer to that.

Q: Don't have any suspicions?

MR. PARDEW: No, not that I'm going into here. (Chuckles.)

Q: (Chuckles.)

MR. PARDEW: Okay –

MS. TAFT: He's guns, I'm butter. Any other – other questions? (Laughs.) (Laughter.)"1

Ambassador James Pardew was sent by Washington to Macedonia in July 2001 with a mandate to "disarm" the NLA-KLA terrorists and implement a US-EU brokered "cease-fire." "No laughing matter": recent developments in Macedonia confirm that Washington rather than disarming the terrorists is in fact equipping them with brand new weapons "Made in America."

Note:

  1. Federal News Service, State Department Briefing on Kosovo, Washington, November 13, 1998.

For details on how Washington has armed and equipped the KLA, see the following articles by the author:

Michel Chossudovsky is Professor of Economics, University of Ottawa, and author of The Globalization of Poverty, second enlarged edition, Common Courage Press, 2001.

Copyright by Michel Chossudovsky, Ottawa, June 2001. All rights reserved. Permission is granted to post this text on non-commercial community internet sites, provided the essay remains intact and the copyright note is displayed and no lengthy headers or footers are added without consulting the author. To publish this text on commercial internet sites, in printed and/or other forms (including excerpts) contact the author at chossudovsky@videotron.ca, fax: 1-514-4256224.

Back to Antiwar.com Home Page | Contact Us