The War Party Conquers Cato?

A few months ago, Mark Brady, over at the Liberty and Power blog, noted that the libertarian Cato Institute had not published or posted anything about the Iraq war since the beginning of the year. Hmmmmm, I thought: an ill wind blows. It wasn’t a good sign for the venerable libertarian thinktank, which opposed Gulf War I, and – despite a few wobbles – stood up against the second Iraq war. However, I knew that a growing neocon contingent within Cato – including longtime apparatchik Tom Palmer, and policy analyst Brink Lindsay – supported the war, with Palmer coming out in a special Cato brochure calling for the military “defeat” of the insurgency, and traveling to Iraq to “advise” the National Assembly and campaign for the “Islam is the law” Iraqi constitution. In this context, the sudden involuntary departure of defense policy director Charles V. Pena, the respected defense policy analyst and staunch anti-interventionist, paints a troubling picture of an institution in the throes of a pro-war purge.

The earlier (voluntary) departure of Ivan Eland, who is now with the Independent Institute – and a regular columnist – was a portent of things to come, and Pena’s departure is but the latest sign that Cato is going over to the War Party. As one observer put it: “Fortunately, Ted Carpenter and Chris Preble are still there but who knows what their future is. I think the jury is still out, but it’s hard not to read between the lines.”

According to a source at Cato, Pena was told that the institute needed to cut staff to close a 7-figure budget deficit. Yet only one other person (not a policy director and not someone in the defense and foreign policy department) was let go (at the end of August). Curiously enough, the day after he was RIF’ed (yes, that’s the term they used: “reduction in force”) Cato President Ed Crane announced the promotion of no less than 4 people at Cato (with each presumably receiving a raise) and the hiring of a new director of government affairs. Also, there’s been plenty of talk about adding 3 floors to the building — to accommodate a larger staff.

What’s going on at Cato is not a “reduction in force,” but a betrayal of libertarian principle. Pena, a senior fellow with the Coalition for a Realistic Foreign Policy, has been a strong advocate of withdrawing from Iraq – a position that Cato is now dropping. This is typical of the Cato crowd: their opportunism has always been beset by bad timing. At the dawn of the Republican-led anti-government revolution, they were telling the world they were “low tax liberals.” Now that the majority of Americans have turned against this war, the Cato bigwigs are lining up with the neoconservatives who want to “stay the course.”

These people, in short, are perpetual losers, who are constantly two steps behind the Zeitgeist and care only about sucking up to Power. They believe that selling out the vitally important principle of a noninterventionist foreign policy is a necessary step on their road to respectability. The reality is that, by aligning themselves with the War Party, which is on the brink of crashing and burning, along with the colonial regime in Iraq, they are consigning themselves to oblivion – and a richly deserved one, at that.

I am reminded of what Murray N. Rothbard said of the Catoites back in the 1980s, when they were trying to pass off libertarianism as “low-tax liberalism”: “They have sold out for a mess of pottage,” he wrote, “without even getting the pottage in return.”

UPDATE: Whoa! The mail is flying in over this one! (Libertarians love gossip.) At least one emailer informs me that I might not have the whole story: while it is true that others were promoted over Pena, it seems that one of them was the heroic Justin Logan, whose blog is a delight (sure, we disagreed about the Yushchenko affair, but now that I’ve been proven right, who cares?). Logan is a hardcore — and very knowledgeable — opponent of interventionism, and he’s a good writer, too.

I am also reminded that good old Ed Crane hates the neocons, and that they couldn’t find a more formidable enemy than the chief cog in the “Crane Machine. ”

So, while the neos have a foothold in the biggest bastion of libertarian opposition to the Warfare State in the Imperial City, they haven’t conquered it — yet! In any case, we’re watching them very closely — and you can bet they know it.

319 thoughts on “The War Party Conquers Cato?”

  1. Our top rated, gym quality E95 features a fluid natural motion provided by a whisper quiet drive system that functions in both forward and reverse motion. The combination of a heavy 34 lb flywheel and high gear ration means an extremely smooth feel with 20 levels of resistance that will provide a challenging workout. The moving handlebars are adjustable for comfort and the stationary handle bars have pulse sensors for monitoring your heart rate. Oversize foot pedals that Sole engineers have designed with a 2 degree inward cant reduce ankle and knee stress. The footbeds also articulate for optimal user comfort and performance. The easy to use console features a 6.5" LCD display, cooling fans and built in speakers for any MP3 player, iPod, etc. for easy listening.

  2. THE MOST EFFECTIVE PHYTOCERAMIDES ON AMAZON – Kaybo Health’s Phytoceramides only use premium quality, scientifically tested ingredients, and vegetarian capsules. Manufactured in the USA, in an FDA-approved facility with strict adherence to Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP). Every batch is 3rd party tested to guarantee the purity and quality of the ingredients. All ingredients used are from the clinical trials that have shown significant skin enhancement.

  3. KayBo Health is dedicated to providing our customers with the best quality weight loss and beauty supplements on the market today. Only the best ingredients go into our products which are made at home in the United States. The preparation of our products is also 100% strictly governed by GMP guidelines to ensure the best quality products.

  4. Different breeds require different care, you have to choose the right kind of food, and you have to understand the health problems that can afflict them.

  5. Each fish oil capsule provides you Pharmaceutical Grade Omega-3 EPA and DHA (2 x plus the amount of other retail fish oil). Start experiencing the comfort of:

    ~ Less Joint & Muscle Pain ~ Improved Mental Sharpness ~ Heart Support ~ Lifts Mood Naturally ~ Boosts Weight-Loss ~ Immune Support ~ Nourishes Skin ~ Boosts Memory & Focus ~ More Energy

Comments are closed.