Pulitizer Prize Winner Seymour Hersh first revealed
– and neocrazy sycophants at the New York Times, Washington Post,
CNN and UPI reluctantly confirmed – that the Bush-Cheney Administration has
been conducting secret "reconnaissance" missions inside Iran since
at least last summer.
"Much of the focus is on the accumulation of intelligence and targeting
information on Iranian nuclear, chemical, and missile sites, both declared
and suspected. The goal is to identify and isolate three dozen, and perhaps
more, such targets that could be destroyed by precision strikes and short-term
Now, Iran is a signatory to the Treaty on Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons,
the Chemical Weapons Convention, and to the Convention on the Prohibition of
the Development, Production and Stockpiling of Bacteriological (Biological)
and Toxin Weapons.
Each convention requires that certain activities and sites be declared by each
party to the conventions. Each also provides for the reporting of the suspicions
by one party – the US for example – of activities and sites that should have
been declared by another party, but weren't.
Iran has been a signatory to the NPT since 1970.
More than a year ago, Iran voluntarily subjected itself to an intrusive go-anywhere
see-anything Additional Protocol to their Safeguards Agreement with the International
Atomic Energy Agency. Under the Additional Protocol, activities and sites that
formerly did not need to be declared at all, or only after operations involving
"special nuclear materials" began, must now be declared while still
in the planning stage.
If IAEA inspectors were to discover that Iran was violating its Safeguards
Agreement, they would report those violations to the IAEA Board of Governors.
If and only if the Board decided the violations amounted to a violation of the
NPT, itself, the Board would refer the matter to the UN Security Council for
The IAEA has now visited every site the Iranians have declared under the Additional
Protocol, as well as at least two sites the US suspected ought to have been
declared, but weren't. Result? The IAEA has found no indication that Iran is
now pursuing – or ever has pursued – a nuclear weapons program.
Iran has been a party to the CWC ever since it
entered into force on April 29, 1997.
The CWC is implemented by the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical
Weapons. The OPCW receives states-parties' declarations, which detail chemical
weapons-related activities or materials and relevant industrial activities.
After receiving declarations, the OPCW inspects and monitors states-parties'
facilities and activities, including chemical weapons-related facilities and
chemical industry facilities to verify the content of declarations and to confirm
that activities are consistent with CWC obligations.
But the OPCW can also conduct "challenge inspections" at any facility
or location in states-parties to clarify questions of possible noncompliance.
If the US suspects that Iran is engaged in prohibited activities at any site,
it is their duty to report that to the OPCW.
If the OPCW determines that the Iranians are engaged in activities that could
result in "serious damage" to the CWC, the OPCW could recommend to
other parties that collective punitive action – such as economic sanctions –
be taken. If the prohibited activities are of "particular gravity,"
the OPCW is required to bring the issue before the UN Security Council for possible
Iran has been a signatory of BTWC since it entered
into force on 26 March 1975.
Each State Party to the BTWC undertakes to never develop, produce, stockpile
or otherwise acquire or retain:
- Microbial or other biological agents, or toxins whatever their origin or
method of production, of types and in quantities that have no justification
for prophylactic, protective or other peaceful purposes;
- Weapons, equipment or means of delivery designed to use such agents or toxins
for hostile purposes or in armed conflict.
The BTWC does not provide for verification or monitoring of compliance. However,
"Any State Party to this convention which finds that any other State Party
is acting in breach of obligations deriving from the provisions thereof may
lodge a complaint with the Security Council of the United Nations. Such a complaint
should include all possible evidence confirming its validity, as well as a request
for its consideration by the Security Council."
Operation Iranian Freedom
So, the US is effectively required to report any
"suspicious" activities and sites their recon teams find in Iran to
the IAEA or OPCW or directly to the UN Security Council for possible action.
But, the Brits have already warned Bush: "If you launch Operation Iranian
Freedom, you'll have to go it alone."