February 28, 2001

Revolution as Tourist Attraction?

The Zapatista Liberation Front from the Mexican province of Chiapas, along with various hangers-on, is marching from its stronghold in the south to Mexico City to confer with Mexican president Vicente Fox, who has just assumed power and has made resolution of the largely indigenous-based revolt in Chiapas a relatively high priority. You wonít get me to predict whether a resolution of the conflict is likely or not. But the revolt in Chiapas has been a fascinating one, however it turns out, that could have implications for other groups seeking to get the attention of (as my friend Richard Cowan of marijuananews.com always puts it) "the appalling people who rule us."

By all reports, the 1,800-mile, two-week trek to Mexico City has more of a carnival atmosphere than the aura of militant anger. As a piece by Laurence Iliff for the Dallas Morning News put it, "the script was different than first envisioned as rebels and sympathizers departed the colonial city of San Cristobal de las Casas where the uprising began in 1994.

Back then the pipe-smoking Subcommandante Marcos and his cohorts had envisioned or pretended to envision something like a military conquest of the oppressive central government in Mexico City. However, as Iliff put it, "Rather than confiscating tanks and military transport trucks and leaving behind defeated government soldiers, the Zapatistas began the first leg of their journey amid a parade-like celebration of rented buses and private vehicles, unarmed and prepared to talk.

SHOULD IT BE ZAPPA-TISTAS?

A not-half-bad radio report from Gerry Hadden of National Public Radio added some color to the story. With Subcommandante Marcos something of a pop culture hero and supporters from around the world joining the march, the event had almost the atmosphere of a rock concert, said Hadden. More celebratory than angry, the Chiapas rebels seemed in a party mood. Whether they will be able to parlay their triumphalism into concessions from Vicente Fox (whom Marcos, in what might have been a downer moment, called a man "who talks a lot and listens very little") is another question.

Perhaps more important is whether the kind of concessions the rebels seem to want theyíre a bit vague, centered around economic assistance from the central government to the poverty-stricken region would be good for the area if they were forthcoming. Grabbing goodies from a central government hardly seems like a formula for independence and pride.

But for now the mood is festive. Perhaps at this point the movement is more like one inspired by rock rebels like Frank Zappa than by revered 1910 revolutionary forebears like Emiliano Zapata.

INTERNET RECRUITING

Among the interesting aspects of the Chiapas rebellion highlighted by the NPR report is the fact that much of the recruiting, both conceptual and physical, for the Zapatista rebels has taken place over the Internet. The movement Web sites, according to Hadden, have played on a sense that the Chiapas indigenous people have the same cause as oppressed indigenous or powerless people the world over, from the Kurds of Iraq to the people of Brazilian and Indonesian rain forests.

This encouragement of a common identity of oppression has drawn college students from Mexico City and most of the European countries, Italian communists and U.S. peace activists, to support the Zappatista rebellion, not just with good wishes and occasional donations, but with their physical presence. Leftist causes that havenít yet been blemished by the corruption and personal scandal that eventually overtake most movements for social change are hardly a dime a dozen these days, and Subcommandante Marcos and his friends have played on the desire to be a part of a lofty cause, to be a part of what seems to be the action.

BUILD IT AND THEY WILL COME?

So successful has the movement been at reviving tattered idealistic hopes that foreign visitors to Chiapas, hoping to make contact with the latest example of revolutionary fervor, have become an important aspect of the local economy. Gerry Hadden talked to several local shopkeepers, including some who didnít have a business or much hopes of ever developing one before the rebellion started attracting foreigners with money to spend.

One merchant even suggested that if a peace agreement were reached it could have a deleterious impact on the local economy. Agriculture in the region is hardly flourishing and commerce and manufacturing are if anything in worse shape. So the businesses that have arisen to cater to foreign tourists in search of the frisson of being part of a revolutionary movement with little if any actual physical danger involved have become a larger share of the economy than might have been anticipated by anyone.

HARDLY A SOLID BASE

Now I donít know if Subcommandante Marcos and the guerillas he leads are really socialists concerned about the dehumanizing effects of globalization or whether they mouth these trendy phrases because they know who their target audience is. If they are sincere in their desire for the subsidies and central controls that accompany socialism, of course, they are asking not for economic help and development but for isolation and continued poverty.

The most important requisite for a solidly based economic development, of course, is relative peace. Wars and conflicts do create opportunities for profiteers of various kinds, of course, and this one seems to have done so on a relatively small scale. But real economic growth is more often rooted in stability, predictability and willingness to make agreements with others whose ultimate interests may be a bit different from oneís own. Recognition of the importance of private property and something resembling a rule of law wouldnít hurt either. But a semblance of domestic tranquility is the most fundamental precondition.

ACT GLOBALLY, THINK LOCALLY

Whether they use the words or not, the Zappatistas may have a glimmer of understanding of some of these issues, and Vicente Fox has more than a glimmer. The experience of the rebels with Internet recruiting in some ways stands as a case study of the ability of globalization to reinforce local identities and causes. By creating an Internet-based virtual community of people who seem to or claim to share certain ideals and are willing to make a commitment to the essentially local cause, the Chiapas guerrillas have used globalization to strengthen localization.

Do they understand that this aspect of globalization – that a day is arriving when people in almost any part of the world can do business (in the broadest sense) with people in almost any other part of the world, which can make them less dependent on local and national political power structures and reinforce their uniques cultural or ethnic identities? I donít know. Often people who have accomplished a conceptually important task are the last to understand its true nature.

Whether the Zappatistas will make a deal with the central government that reduces the level of violence and begins the process of facilitating economic development or not, the atmosphere of a rock concert is a more attractive way to run a revolution than the grim anger and killing that often accompanies a rebel movement. The Chiapas guerrillas seem somewhat ideologically befuddled. But itís hard not to wish them well.

Please Support Antiwar.com

A contribution of $50 or more will get you a copy of Ronald Radosh's out-of-print classic study of the Old Right conservatives, Prophets on the Right: Profiles of Conservative Critics of American Globalism. Send contributions to

Antiwar.com
520 S. Murphy Avenue, #202
Sunnyvale, CA 94086

or Contribute Via our Secure Server
Credit Card Donation Form

or


Have an e-gold account?
Contribute to Antiwar.com via e-gold.
Our account number is 130325

Text-only printable version of this article

Alan Bock is Senior Essayist at the Orange County Register and a weekly columnist for WorldNetDaily. He is the author of Ambush at Ruby Ridge (Putnam-Berkley, 1995). He is also author of the forthcoming book Waiting to Inhale: The Politics of Medical Marijuana (Seven Locks Press). His exclusive column now appears every Wednesday on Antiwar.com.

Archived Columns by
Alan Bock

Revolution as Tourist Attraction?
2/28/01

Bombing for . . . What?
2/21/01

Middle East: A Time for Reassessment
2/14/01

Tussling in the Bush Foreign Policy Team?
2/7/01

Bush Team: Good People, No Larger Vision Yet
1/31/01

Dubyaís Foreign Policy Could Depend On Us
1/24/01

Clinton's Sad Foreign Policy Legacy
1/17/01

Mixed peace prospects in Northern Ireland
1/10/01

Remembering Alan Cranston
1/3/01

Scoping out Condoleezza Rice
12/27/00

Israeli Wild Cards in the Peace Process
12/13/00

Making Lemonade
12/6/00

The Will to Power
11/29/00

A Peace Platform?
11/22/00

To The Mattresses
11/15/00

Undermining the Empire
11/9/00

Colombia Ignored in Campaign
11/1/00

Another Missed Opportunity?
10/18/00

Imperial Meddling in Jerusalem
10/11/00

Sad Triumph of Reality
10/4/00

Promoting or Deterring Democracy?
9/28/00

Wen Ho Lee, John Deutch and the Future of Intelligence
9/21/00

A Libertarian Alternative for Voters
9/13/00

Colombia Morass
9/6/00

It's Good to be King
8/30/00

Chiapas and Mexican Prospects
8/23/00

None But the Scruffy
8/16/00

Hard Choices the Parties are Avoiding
8/9/00

Peace in Kashmir? Maybe Not
8/2/00

Failing to Endorse a False Peace
7/26/00

The Last Camp David
7/19/00

Debunking the Greatest Generation
7/12/00

New World Order: The Bosnian Model
7/5/00

Into a New Quagmire
6/28/00

Korean Surprises
6/21/00

Who Could Deplore Peace Prospects?
6/14/00

Defending General McCaffrey
6/7/00

McCaffrey Bites Back
5/24/00

McCaffrey a War Criminal?
5/17/00

The Mainstream Catches Up
5/10/00

Gore's Gory Plans
5/3/00

The State's True Colors
4/27/00

NATO's Sheer Incompetence: A Larger Meaning?
4/20/00

Talkin' Empire Blues
4/13/00

Doubts about Colombian Intervention
4/6/00

The War Party and the Media
3/30/00

Blockading OPEC/ War on Drugs
3/23/00

Human Rights and Trade Policies
3/16/00

New Doubts About Intervention
3/9/00

Big Money and Colombian Intervention
3/2/00

Toward An American Foreign Policy II
2/24/00

Toward An American Foreign Policy
2/17/00

Russian Developments and Austrian Absurdities
2/10/00

The Absence of the War Issue
2/3/00

Madeleine's Dubious Endorsement
1/27/00

Costs of Immigration Control
1/20/00

Colombian Drug War Heating Up
1/13/00

Sheperdstown is All About Clinton
1/6/00

Giving Peace a Chance
(12/30/99)

Fear and Trembling in the Imperial Camp
(12/23/99)

Worrying About the Russian Army
(12/16/99)

The Need for Enemies, Once Again
(12/9/99)

The First Casualty
(12/2/99)

Dubya's Expansive Vision
(11/25/99)

The Forbes Disappointment
(11/18/99)

Honoring Veterans/ Greece/ Timor (11/11/99)

Iraq Military Buildup/ Baltic News (11/4/99)

Sudan Second Thoughts (10/28/99)

Embassy Questions Persist (10/21/99)

Colombian Sting/ Pakistan Peculiarities (10/14/99)

War Drums Over Colombia (10/7/99)

Colombia Still Heating Up/ East Timor: Empty Justifications (9/30/99)

Which Way, Old World? (9/23/99)

Timor Complications (9/16/99)

A Timorous Expedition/ Kosovo/ Colombia (9/9/99)

The Military in the Post-Cold War Era (9/2/99)

The Itch to Choose Sides/ Sudanese Anniversary (8/26/99)

Bosnia Scandal/ Richard Butler/ Iraq/ Kosovo (8/19/99)

Colombia Clarifications/ End Selective Service (8/12/99)

Colombia: The Next War/ Embassies in the Next Century (8/5/99)

The Empire's Casual Casualties/ Bulgarian Repercussions (7/29/99)

Lessons in Failing Interventions (7/22/99)

Kashmir: Will Bill and Maddie Intervene?/ A Republic or an Empire? (7/15/99)

Kosovo: Learning the Wrong Lessons (Mostly) (7/8/99)

George Dubya and American "Leadership" (7/1/99)

Your Contributions are now Tax-deductible

Back to Antiwar.com Home Page | Contact Us