You consider war to be inevitable? Very good. Let everyone who advocates war be enrolled in a special regiment of advance-guards, for the front of every storm, of every attack, to lead them all!
Leo Tolstoy
Original Blog US Casualties Contact Donate

October 10, 2006

Bye-Bye, Civil Liberties

Thanks, Democrats

by Joshua Frank

I'm still wondering where all the damn outrage is, and I'm not talking about the Foley scandal. On Sept. 29, the Senate voted 100-0 in favor of the pork-swollen Pentagon budget, which earmarked $70 billion for our ongoing military ventures in Iraq and Afghanistan. There was no debate over the appropriation, and not one Democrat voted against the egregious spending. On the same day, the Senate also overwhelmingly approved the dismantling of habeas corpus for "enemy combatants." Twelve Democrats sided with the Republicans to allow the U.S. government to detain people arbitrarily and indefinitely.

We shouldn't be all that surprised the Democrats didn't filibuster the awful bill, which also expanded the definition of "enemy combatant" to include anyone who "has purposefully and materially supported hostilities against the United States," whatever that's supposed to mean. No, the Democrats have long been on the front lines of the federal government's assault on our civil liberties.

In fact, what we are seeing today is just a logical continuation of a foundation laid during the Clinton era. Before the now well-known PATRIOT Act there was the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act, which was signed into law following the Oklahoma City bombing of April 19, 1995.

"The act was wide-ranging, dealing with everything from the making of plastic explosives to trading in nuclear materials," writes Georgetown law professor David Cole and James X. Dempsey in Terrorism and the Constitution.

"Members of Congress immediately felt tremendous pressure to pass anti-terrorism legislation," Cole and Dempsey recall. "It did not matter that the proposals in the president's initial bill were directed largely against international terrorism, while the Oklahoma bombing was the work of homegrown discontents. … Eager to get the bill on the president's desk by the April 19 anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing, the Senate adopted the conference report on April 17 in a 91-8 vote. The next day, the House also adopted the report by a vote of 293-133. On April 24, President Clinton signed the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996."

"To make the death penalty effective," explains civil liberties expert Elaine Cassel in The War on Civil Liberties, "meant making it harder to appeal convictions of capital offenses." Clinton's law, says Cassel, also "[made] it a crime to support even the lawful activities of an organization labeled as terrorist … [authorized] the FBI to investigate the crime of 'material support' for terrorism based solely on activities protected under the First Amendment … [froze the] assets of any U.S. citizen or domestic organization believed to be an agent of a terrorist group, without specifying an 'agent' … [expanded] the powers of the secret court … [repealed] the law that barred the FBI from opening investigations based solely on activities protected under the First Amendment … [and allowed] the Immigration and Naturalization Service (now called the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) to deport citizens (mostly Muslims) upon the order of INS officials."

Of course, these are but a few of the ways in which the Clinton administration infringed upon civil liberties. Speaking of the legacy of these breaches of our guaranteed civil liberties, Clinton himself admitted to making "a number of ill-advised changes in our immigration laws, having nothing to do with fighting terrorism."

Sounds familiar, doesn't it?

In the wake of Sept. 11, it wasn't surprising that Clinton's successor George W. Bush legislated additional infringements upon civil liberties in the name of patriotism and national security. And yes, the Democrats overwhelmingly supported the PATRIOT Act in both of its awful versions. But it wasn't the PATRIOT Act that allowed the federal government to make those sweeping detentions across the country immediately following 9/11 – it was Clinton's Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty bill.

So who is honestly supposed to believe that ushering the Democrats back into office in November will bring any sort of legitimate change – in Iraq or back at home?

comments on this article?

  • The Blood on Holbrooke's Hands

  • No Comment and
    No Leadership From Obama

  • That Other Military Draft

  • Barack Obama's Israel Bond

  • MoveOn's Obama Endorsement

  • Why Bush Wants to Legalize the Nuke Trade with Turkey

  • Antiwar Left Should Look Beyond Democrats

  • Broken Promises and Barefaced Lies

  • The Problem with Barack Obama's Israel Pose

  • Time to Put Politics (and Dem Politicians) Aside

  • Hillary Clinton and
    the Israel Lobby

  • Wake Me When It's Over

  • Snake Oil and the
    Midterm Elections

  • Bye-Bye, Civil Liberties

  • Kidnapped in Israel or Captured in Lebanon?

  • Hillary May Be Presidential Material, After All

  • The Democrats'
    Election-Year Stunts

  • Zarqawi and Lesser-Evil Politics

  • Holding the War Parties Accountable

  • Leftists for Occupation

  • Save Darfur?

  • Challenging Hillary Clinton

  • Kerry's Halfhearted Reversal

  • A War in Search of a Justification

  • Twist and Hate

  • The Democrats'
    Daddy Warbucks

  • Senator Feinstein's War Profiteering

  • Redeployment: Another Election-Year Stunt

  • Who's the Bigger Hawk, George or Hillary?

  • MoveOn.org Surrenders

  • Bird-Dogging Hillary Clinton

  • Hillary in the Holy Land

  • Talking Points Propaganda

  • Washington Democrats: No Will, No Backbone

  • In Defense of Lew Rockwell

  • You Can't Fight 'Ists' and 'Isms'

  • Top Democrats Flee Peace Protests

  • NYPD Unplugs Cindy Sheehan, but Not the Antiwar Movement

  • Bunny Bugs the War Profiteers

  • The Democrats and Cindy Sheehan

  • Gitmo's Kangaroo Court

  • With Hand on Heart: Pelosi Admits Israel Comes First

  • Horowitz's Gang Smears the Dead

  • Support the Troops, Oppose Their Actions

  • 'Dead Wrong' and Probably Not for the Last Time

  • Howard Dean Still Selling Out the Antiwar Movement

  • The War Path of Unity

  • Recovering From Kerry

  • Democrats and Iran: Look Who Supports Bush's Next War
  • Joshua Frank is the author of Left Out!: How Liberals Helped Reelect George W. Bush, just published by Common Courage Press. You can order a copy at a discounted through Josh's blog at www.brickburner.org. He can be reached at brickburner@gmail.com.

    Reproduction of material from any original Antiwar.com pages
    without written permission is strictly prohibited.
    Copyright 2017 Antiwar.com