December 29, 2003

POPE JOHN PAUL II: MAN OF THE YEAR
He stood up to the War Party

by Justin Raimondo

Even as Glenn Reynolds, Supreme Pontiff of the Blogosphere and hater of all things Catholic, was demanding an apology from Pope John Paul II for opposing the "liberation" of Iraq, rumors were rife that the Vatican was threatened by a possible terrorist attack launched by Al Qaeda. All the bad guys, no matter what branch of evil they adhere to, hate the Holy Father because he represents the one force with international stature that stands against them.

On the eve of the Iraq invasion, the Vatican carried out a full-scale diplomatic, political, and theological assault on the War Party. The Pope sent his representative to Baghdad, and tried to arrange a peaceful settlement: the Iraqis, as we now know, were amenable. But this effort was disdainfully rejected by Washington and viciously attacked by the neoconservatives, who initiated a round of anti-Papist demagoguery not seen since the 1880s, when the Republican party rallied the nation against "rum, Romanism, and rebellion."

Just imagine the uproar if this had happened to a rabbi.

As millions mobilized in the streets, the Pope sent a message to Catholic military chaplains endorsing the antiwar movement in rather explicit terms: this showed, he said, that a "large part of humanity" has rejected war, except in self-defense against an aggressor, and, he added, the peace movement gave him a great deal of "comfort and hope."

In his 2002 Christmas message, John Paul had called on the governments of the world to make an urgent effort "in the Middle East, to extinguish the ominous smoldering of a conflict which, with the joint efforts of all, can be avoided." This year, with resistance to the American occupation growing, and domestic antiwar sentiment persisting, the War Party was nervously anticipating his annual "Urbi et Orbi" (the City and the World) message, and he did not disappoint:

"Save us from the great evils which rend humanity in these first years of the third millennium. Save us from the wars and armed conflicts which lay waste whole areas of the world, from the scourge of terrorism and from the many forms of violence which assail the weak and the vulnerable. Save us from discouragement as we face the paths to peace, difficult paths indeed, yet possible and therefore necessary; paths which are always and everywhere urgent, especially in the Land where You were born, the Prince of Peace."

God save us from George W. Bush. Save us from his neocon advisors, who would rather plunge us into what they call World War IV than ask Ariel Sharon to give an inch of ground. Save us from a Vice President who sends out a creepy Christmas card citing Benjamin Franklin's remark to the Constitutional Convention:

"And if a sparrow cannot fall to the ground without His notice, is it probable that an empire can rise without His aid?'

The Church stands foursquare against the hubris of earthly kings who delude themselves into thinking they can act like gods. It is the main organized obstacle to any nation with pretensions of universal hegemony, and the papacy of John Paul II has exemplified the role of the Church as the protector of humanity against the depredations of the State. What is astonishing to see is the sheer superhuman strength of this man, whose suffering is a modern-day reenactment of the Stations of the Cross.

Here we have an 83-year-old burdened by a series of physical ailments that would have any ordinary human being curled up in a fetal position, yet he has just finished up a grueling years-long schedule of trips that took him to at least three continents. This Pope is the peace party's Gandalf: no matter how battered, incapacitated, and beaten down he may seem, he always comes back at Sauron.

If John Paul is Gandalf, then Michael Novak, the neocons' pet "theologian," is Saruman, the liar and deceiver. Novak and a delegation – including William Bennett and Andrew Sullivan, two of the biggest sinners in the Western world – were sent to Rome by the U.S. State Department to convince the Vatican to support the war: or, at least, to neutralize Catholic opposition. During the course of a two-hour symposium attended by some 150 invited guests, including lower-level Vatican officials, Novak made the transparently spurious argument that the war was not a preemptive one, but rather a war for self-defense:

"On one side, Iraq maintains weapons of mass destruction, and on the other, international terrorists are seeking to procure them.

"'All that is lacking between these two incendiary elements is a spark of contact,' Novak said."

"'Given Saddam's proven record in the use of such weapons, and given his recognized contempt for international law, only an imprudent or even foolhardy statesman could trust that these two forces will stay apart forever. At any time they could combine, in secret, to murder tens of thousands of innocent and unsuspecting citizens,' he said."

Only U.S. government officials, he argued, have the inside knowledge about Saddam's possession of such weapons, and we must trust in them and not in the Pope to make these decisions. That these officials were lying, and their case for war a web a deceit, does not have Novak begging the Holy Father's forgiveness. Novak and his cohorts, far from repentant, are walking arguments in favor of the Pope's power to excommunicate heretics.

Although I was raised a Catholic, I am not a believer. But I must recognize the moral stature of a man like John Paul II, who stood up to the Communist would-be hegemon and is now standing up to another. As he said in a speech to the Vatican diplomatic corps:

"What are we to say of the threat of a war that could strike the people of Iraq, the land of the prophets, a people already sorely tried by more than 12 years of embargo? War is never just another means that one can choose to employ for settling differences between nations. As the Charter of the United Nations Organization and international law itself remind us, war cannot be decided upon, even when it is a matter of ensuring the common good, except as the very last option and in accordance with very strict conditions, without ignoring the consequences for the civilian population both during and after the military operations."

Even the most hardcore militant atheists in the antiwar movement must recognize and salute the moral authority of the Church, whose foreign minister, Archbishop Jean-Louis Tauran, expressed the view of those of us in the U.S. who resist the rise of an American empire:

"A single member of the international community cannot decide: 'I'm doing this and you others can either help me or stay home.' If that were the case, the entire system of international rules would collapse. We'd risk the jungle."

Cardinal Renato Martino, head of the Peace and Justice Commission known as the Donald Rumsfeld of the Vatican because of his tough-as-nails approach to promulgating the Pope's mission of peace put it succinctly and well:

"We cannot think that there is a universal policeman who takes it upon himself to punish those who act badly.... The United States, being part of the international assembly, has to adapt to the exigencies of others."

There is no universal policeman and ruler of mortal mien worthy of the task, and any scheme to set one up is necessarily Satanic.

This may come as news to militantly secular antiwar lefties, and nasty left-libertarians willfully ignorant of all things theological, but the institutional power of the Vatican and the Roman Catholic hierarchy has been a mighty weapon in the arsenal of peace.

Pope John Paul II, a giant among men, who has single-handedly taken on the power of the War Party – and who towers so far above his critics that the distance can only be measured in light years is our Man of the Year.

NOTES IN THE MARGIN

My continuing campaign to get loudmouth warmonger Neal Boortz booted from the podium of the Libertarian Party's upcoming national convention has suffered a setback. The Libertarian National Committee recently voted to affirm their invitation to the noted Bush shill: the vote was 9 to 6. Here is the text of the resolution they passed:

"The LNC supports our Convention Committee's invitation to Neal Boortz to speak at our national convention in Atlanta in May 2004. We do not condition participation at our convention on membership in the LP or on 100% compliance with the national party platform. We welcome the continued efforts of Mr. Boortz and many others to further the freedom movement in whatever way they choose."

What hypocrites! If Boortz opposed the legalization of, say, marijuana, cloning, or any of the other favored left-libertarian hobby-horses, we all know he wouldn't be able to get within a country mile of the speakers' platform in Atlanta. Leave it to the politically clueless "leadership" of the LP to consign the party's opposition to the war the one platform plank with potentially broad appeal this election year to the junk heap. No wonder they've begun to limit their pathetic electoral efforts to getting elected to local county water board and community college and sewer districts. The LP doesn't care about the bad public relations this decision is already generating they stupidly believe that any publicity is good publicity. What a way to commit suicide.

Oh well, don't get mad get even! There's just one way to register your disapproval of the LP NatCom's decision: if you're planning to contribute to the Libertarian Party, to renew your membership, or vote for their generally dumb-ass candidates, don't do it.

And let them know why.

Send email to the convention coordinator, Nancy Neale (who just happens to be the wife of the current National Chairman), at torchess@austin.rr.com.

Or call the National Libertarian Party, at: (202) 333-0008, or contact members of the Libertarian Party National Committee.

– Justin Raimondo

comments on this article?

 Please Support Antiwar.com

Antiwar.com
1017 El Camino Real #306
Redwood City, CA 94063

or Contribute Via our Secure Server
Credit Card Donation Form

Your contributions are now tax-deductible

Antiwar.com Home Page

Most recent column by Justin Raimondo

Archived columns

Pope John Paul II: Man of the Year
12/29/03

A Fearful Christmas
12/24/03

Libya: Will the US Take Yes for an Answer?
12/22/03

Kean on the Truth
12/19/03

Will Saddam Cut a Deal?
12/17/03

Saddam, Celebrity Tyrant
12/15/03

Neocons Turning on Bush?
12/12/03

Now They're After Putin
12/10/03

Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?
12/8/03

Going AWOL
12/5/03

Showdown in Samarra
12/3/03

Crocodile Teardrops
12/1/03

Classic Raimondo:
Is Iraq Next?
11/28/03

Go F*ck Yourself, Mr. President
11/26/03

FBI Eye on the Antiwar Guy
11/24/03

Conrad Black and the Corruption of Empire
11/21/03

The Bizarro Effect
11/19/03

The Neocons Are Losing
11/17/03

Classic Raimondo:
A Mandate for War?
11/14/03

Iraq: It's Getting Ugly
11/12/03

George W. Bush, Trotskyite
11/10/03

Classic Raimondo:
Ein Volk, Ein Fuehrer, Ein Israel...
11/7/03

The Last Senator
11/5/03

The Deadliest Day
11/3/03

Iraq and Vietnam
10/31/03

Chickenhawk Sees Combat
10/29/03

Our 'Friends,' the Israelis
10/27/03

Rummy's Ruminations
10/24/03

Support Our Troops
10/22/03

Exit Stage Iraq?
10/20/03

Googling the War Party
10/17/03

A Day in the Life of the Empire
10/15/03

Fake 'Good News' from Iraq
10/13/03

US War Propaganda Is Pathetic
10/10/03

Hands Off Bob Novak!
10/8/03

Israel Is the Problem
10/6/03

L'Affaire Plame
10/3/03

The Neo-Jacobins
10/1/03

The Costs of War
9/29/03

War Party Whines Over Iraq Coverage
9/26/03

Instead of a Column
9/24/03

Another 9/11?
9/22/03

Are You Syria-ous?
9/19/03

Donald Rumsfeld, Peacenik?
9/17/03

Countdown to Catastrophe in the Middle East
9/15/03

Iraq Is the Flytrap
9/12/03

9/11 Conspiracy Chic
9/10/03

Bush Speech: No U-Turn on the Road to Empire
9/8/03

Imperial Eye for the Republican Guy
9/5/03

Iraq's Mystery Terrorists
9/3/03

The Dean Deception
8/27/03

The War Party Unmasked
8/25/03

America in Iraq: A Glutton for Punishment
8/22/03

Baghdad Bomb Blasted American Hubris
8/20/03

The Neocons Come Out
8/18/03

The Real Terror Masters
8/15/03

Iraq War Critics Purged
8/13/03

A Politically Correct War?
8/11/03

US Troops in Iraq Are Sitting Ducks
8/8/03

Dean vs. Loserman
8/6/03

Anthrax Anniversary
8/4/03

What Does Bush Have to Hide?
8/1/03

Mr. Sharon, Tear Down That Wall!
7/30/03

Who Lied Us Into War?
7/28/03

Bremer's Baghdad Bolsheviks
7/25/03

The Perversion of History
7/23/03

Coalition of Deceit
7/21/03

Military Morale Hits Bottom in Iraq
7/18/03

Saddam Meets the Man From U.N.C.L.E.
7/16/03

Bogus from the Beginning
7/14/03

'If It Feels Good Do It'
7/11/03

Mosaic of Lies
7/9/03

To Heck with Liberia!
7/7/03

Mourning in America
7/4/03

No Exit?
7/2/03

The Road Map
6/30/03

The Culture of Imperialism
6/27/03

The WMD Cult
6/25/03

The New Thought Police
6/23/03

Empire of Liberty?
6/20/03

The Gaza Trap
6/18/03

What's It All About?
6/16/03

Trotsky, Strauss, and the Neocons
6/13/03

Classic Raimondo:
Israel's Taliban
6/11/03

Behind the Lies
6/9/03

Liars 'R Us
6/6/03

Hell to Pay
6/4/03

Wackos, Weirdos and Wing-Dings
6/2/03

We Were Right
5/30/03

On to Tehran?
5/28/03

Classic Raimondo:
Decline and Fall
5/26/03

Outing the Neocons
5/23/03

Revolt Against the Neocons
5/21/03

Regime Change Roulette
5/19/03

Blowback in Riyadh
5/16/03

The Anti-Americans
5/14/03

Classic Raimondo: Living in a Soviet America
5/12/03

Smoking Gun
5/9/03

Mad Dogs of War
5/7/03

Whose 'Road Map'?
5/5/03

The Final Secret of 9/11
5/2/03

Neocons in Denial
4/30/03

Santorum's Sins
4/28/03

The Real Crisis
4/25/03

Screw the UN
4/23/03

Putting America First
4/21/03

Fickle 'Victory'
4/18/03

Nesting Habits of Washington's War Birds
4/16/03

Phase Two Begins
4/14/03

King George Returns
4/9/03

The Real War
4/7/03

World War IV
4/4/03

If This Be Treason
4/2/03

On the Middle East Escalator
3/31/03

A Perle of High Price
3/28/03

Iraqi Pandora
3/26/03

A No-Winner
3/24/03

Commissar Frum
3/22/03

Bluff and Bluster
3/21/03

Shine, Perishing Republic
3/19/03

This Isn't About You
3/17/03

What's It All About, Ari?
3/14/03

Postwar Blues
3/12/03

Reckless Warmongers
3/10/03

This War Is Treason
3/7/03

The Hapless Hegemon
3/5/03

Libertarianism in the Age of Empire
3/3/03

Notes from the Margin
2/28/03

Is War Inevitable?
2/26/03

War Party Stumbles
2/24/03

Vive la France!
2/21/03

A 'Toxic' Meme
2/19/03

Rallying for War
2/17/03

Rally Against Fear
2/14/03

One Battlefield, Two Wars
2/12/03

Antiwar Breakthrough!
2/10/03

The Lying Game
2/7/03

Free Taki!
2/5/03

The Kook Factor
2/3/03

Previous columns

Justin Raimondo is the editorial director of Antiwar.com. He is also the author of Reclaiming the American Right: The Lost Legacy of the Conservative Movement (with an Introduction by Patrick J. Buchanan), (1993), and Into the Bosnian Quagmire: The Case Against U.S. Intervention in the Balkans (1996). He is an Adjunct Scholar with the Ludwig von Mises Institute, in Auburn, Alabama, a Senior Fellow at the Center for Libertarian Studies, and writes frequently for Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture. He is the author of An Enemy of the State: The Life of Murray N. Rothbard.

Back to Antiwar.com Home Page | Contact Us