Karl Rove, then White House deputy chief of staff
for President George W. Bush, received a copy of the secret Iranian proposal
for negotiations with the United States from former Republican Congressman Bob
Ney in early May 2003, according to an Iranian-American scholar who was then
on his Congressional staff.
Ney, who pleaded guilty last year and was sentenced to prison in January for
his role in the Jack Abramov lobbying scandal, was named by former aide Trita
Parsi as an intermediary who took a copy of the Iranian proposal to the White
Parsi is now a specialist on Iranian national security policy and president
of the National Iranian-American Council (NIAC), a non-partisan organization
that supports a negotiated settlement of the conflict between Iran and the United
Parsi revealed that the document was delivered specifically to Rove, in an
exclusive interview with IPS. Within two hours of the delivery of the document,
according to Parsi, Ney received a phone call from Rove confirming his receipt
of the document. Parsi said the proposal was delivered to Rove the same week
that the State Department received it by fax, which was on or about May 4, 2003,
according to the cover letter accompanying it.
Ney was chosen by Swiss Ambassador in Tehran Tim Guldimann to carry the Iranian
proposal to the White House, according to Parsi, because he knew the Ohio Congressman
to be the only Farsi-speaking member of Congress and particularly interested
Guldimann helped the Iranians draft the proposal and passed it on the United
The White House press office had not responded to a request for a comment on
the account naming Rove as the recipient of the Iranian proposal by midday Friday.
The Iranian proposal for negotiations, which suggested that Iran was willing
to consider far-reaching compromises on its nuclear program, relations with
Hezbollah and Hamas and support for a Palestinian peace agreement with Israel
as part of a larger peace agreement with the United States, has become a contentious
issue between the Bush administration and its critics in and out of Congress.
The identification of Rove as a recipient of the secret Iranian proposal throws
new light on the question of who in the Bush administration was aware of the
Iranian proposal at the time. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice denied in
Congressional testimony last week that she had seen the Iranian offer in 2003
and even chastised former State Department, National Security Council and Central
Intelligence Agency official Flynt Leverett for having failed to bring it to
her attention at the time.
At a Capital Hill conference on U.S.-Iran relations Wednesday, sponsored by
the New America Foundation and NIAC, Leverett responded to Rice's criticism
by saying it was "unthinkable that it would not have been brought to her
attention" and demanding an apology from her.
In May 2003, both Rove and Rice were considered to be part of Bush's inner
circle on foreign policy matters, along with Vice President Dick Cheney. When
Bush met with South Korea President Roh Moo-hyun on May 13, for example, the
only advisers accompanying him were Rove and Rice.
The revelation that Rove received a copy of the Iranian negotiating proposal
within days of the receipt of the State Department makes it appear very unlikely
that Rice was not immediately made aware of the document.
The new account of the transmission of a second copy of the Iranian proposal
to the White House coincided with the release Wednesday of both the actual text
of the proposal as received in Washington and of the cover memo by Ambassador
Guldimann which accompanied it. The two documents contradict the suggestion
by Rice and by other State Department officials that Guldimann was acting on
his own in forwarding the proposal, and that it did not reflect the intentions
of the Iranian government.
The two documents were made available on the website of the Washington Post
online edition in connection with a story by Post reporter Glenn Kessler.
wrote that they had been provided by "a source who felt its contents
were mischaracterised by State Department officials."
The memo from Guldimann, dated May 4, confirms previous reports that the Iranian
proposal was drafted by the Iranian Ambassador in Paris Sadeq Kharrazi, in consultation
with Guldimann but only after extensive discussions between Kharrazi and the
three top figures in Iranian foreign policy: Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, then
President Mohammad Khatami and his Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi.
As the memo notes, Ambassador Kharrazi, a former deputy foreign minister, was
extremely well connected to the very top level of Iranian leadership. Khamenei's
son is married to his sister, and the foreign minister is his uncle.
The memo recounts that a first draft of what was to be called a "roadmap"
was done by Ambassador Kharrazi with Guldimann's help during a long discussion
on Apr. 21, 2003. It was that document that Parsi later obtained from Iranian
sources and has been reported in previous accounts of the proposal. After that
initial meeting Kharrazi had two long meetings with Khamenei, President Khatami
and the foreign minister which he reported as lasting a total of four hours.
According to Kharrazi's account, the three leaders agreed on "85%-90%"
of the draft roadmap, with the president and foreign minister voicing no objection
and Khamenei raising "some reservations as for some points." Guldimann
reported in his memo that Kharrazi asked him at a meeting on May 2 to make "some
minor changes in the previous draft," especially on the Middle East peace
In the final draft, which has now been made public, the bullet point on "U.S.
aims" on the Middle East regarding the Palestinian-Israeli peace issue
was changed from "acceptance of the Arab League Beirut declaration (Saudi
initiative, two states-approach)" to simply "acceptance of the two-states-approach."
The intention behind that shift is made clearer by the only other substantive
change in the newly released final draft. In the discussion of a possible "decision
on the first mutual steps" the document suggests that the Iranians would
issue a "statement that it supports a peaceful solution in the Middle East,
that it accepts a solution which is accepted by the Palestinians and that it
follows with interest the discussion on the Roadmap, presented by the Quartet."
That formula would allow the Iranian side to maintain a position of support
for "the Palestinians" in negotiations with Washington.
Guldimann's memo reports that Kharrazi told him all three leaders supported
the initiative. But the Iranian diplomat asked him if he could pass the proposal
"very confidentially to someone very high in the DoS [Department of State]
in order to get to know the U.S. reaction on it." He also warned that,
"if the initiative failed, and if anything about the new Iranian flexibility
outline in it became known, they would also for internal reasons not be
bound by it."
That was a clear indication that the Iranian leaders were afraid that their
conservative critics would attack them if such a proposal did not bring desired
results, charging that it showed weakness.