News that three more prisoners have been released
from Guantánamo is cause for celebration, as all three men should never
have been held in the first place. In a report to follow, I'll look at the stories
of the two Afghans released – one a simple farmer, the other a juvenile at
the time he was seized – but for now I'm going to focus on the extraordinary
story of the prisoner released to Pakistan, Mohammed Saad Iqbal Madni, whose
grotesque mistreatment involves "extraordinary rendition" and torture
spanning several continents.
A Pakistani-Egyptian national and the son of an Islamic scholar, Madni was
24 years old when he was arrested in Jakarta by the Indonesian authorities on
January 9, 2002, after a request from the CIA. He was then rendered to Egypt,
apparently at the urging of the Egyptian authorities, working in cooperation
with the CIA. In Egypt, he was tortured for three months, and was flown back
to Afghanistan on April 12, 2002 with Mamdouh Habib, an Australian prisoner,
seized in Pakistan, who was released in January 2005, and who has spoken
at length about his torture in Egypt. Eleven months later, Madni was transferred
Although Madni did not speak about his treatment during any of his military
reviews at Guantánamo, several prisoners confirmed that he was tortured
by the Egyptians. Rustam Akhmyarov, a Russian prisoner released in 2004, said
that Madni told him of his time "in an underground cell in Egypt, where
he never saw the sun and where he was tortured until he confessed to working
with Osama bin Laden," and added that he "recalled how he was interrogated
by both Egyptian and U.S. agents in Egypt and that he was blindfolded, tortured
with electric shocks, beaten and hung from the ceiling."
Akhmyarov also said that Madni was in a particularly bad mental and physical
state in Guantánamo, where he "was passing blood in his feces,"
and recalled that he overheard U.S. officials telling him, "we will let
you go if you tell the world everything was fine here." Mamdouh Habib confirmed
Akhmyarov's analysis, recalling how Madni had "pleaded for human interaction."
He said that he overheard him saying, "Talk to me, please talk to me ...
I feel depressed ... I want to talk to somebody ... Nobody trusts me."
On the 191st day of his incarceration, according to Madni's own account,
he attempted to commit suicide.
The Tipton Three – Rhuhel Ahmed, Asif Iqbal and Shafiq Rasul, British citizens
released in 2004 – also recalled
Madni in Guantánamo. They said that "he had had electrodes put on
his knees: and that "something had happened to his bladder and he had problems
going to the toilet," but explained that he had been told by interrogators
that he would not receive treatment unless he cooperated with them, in which
case he would be "first in line for medical treatment."
Quite what Madni was supposed to have done to justify this torture and abuse
was never adequately explained at Guantánamo. The U.S. authorities urged
the Indonesians to arrest him after they claimed to have discovered documents
that linked him to Richard Reid, the inept and mentally troubled British "shoe
bomber," who was arrested, and later received a life sentence, for attempting
to blow up an American Airlines flight from Paris to Miami in December 2001,
but Madni persistently denied the connections. In his Combatant Status Review
Tribunal – in which he pointed out that he is from a wealthy and influential
family, is fluent in nine languages and is a renowned Islamic scholar – he
maintained that he was betrayed by one of four radical Islamists whom he met
by accident on a trip to Indonesia in November 2001 to sort out family business
after his father's death.
This account was backed up during an investigation by the Washington
Post, who concluded that he rented a house in Jakarta, and did nothing
more sinister than visiting the local mosque, handing out business cards "identifying
him as a Koran reader for an Islamic radio station," and spending "hours
on end watching television at a friend's house." Succinctly summing up
what happened to him, he told his tribunal, "After I went to Indonesia,
I got introduced to some people who were not good. They were bad people. Maybe
I can say they were terrorists. When someone gets introduced to someone, it
is not written on their foreheads that they are bad or good."
According to Ray Bonner of the New
York Times, the entire basis for Madni's capture, rendition and torture
was that Madni, described by an uncle in Lahore as a young man who "had
a childish habit of trying to portray himself as important," had made the
mistake of telling the men he had met – members of the Islamic Defender Front,
an organization that espoused anti-Americanism, but had not been involved in
an terrorist attacks – that bombs could be hidden in shoes.
The comment was picked up by Indonesian intelligence agents, who were monitoring
the men, and was relayed to the CIA, who decided to pick him up after Richard
Reid's failed shoe bomb attack a few weeks later. Although a U.S. intelligence
official confirmed Madni's uncle's account, calling Madni a "blowhard,"
who "wanted us to believe he was more important than he was," and
another thought that he would be held for a few days, "then booted out
of jail," more senior officials clearly had other plans. Madni's six-and-a-half-year
ordeal, therefore, was based on a single ill-advised comment.
If Madni's family are sufficiently well connected, it may well be that we haven't
heard the last of this particular story of the gruesome impact of torture arrangements
between the United States and Egypt, based on inadequate intelligence, and the
quiescent role of the Indonesian authorities. On the other hand, Madni, if released
in Pakistan, may just want to rebuild his life in seclusion. This would be understandable,
of course, but his abominable treatment deserves to be more than a mere footnote
in the history of the Bush administration's vile and unprincipled policies of
"extraordinary rendition" and torture.
This article draws extensively on passages in Andy Worthington's book, The
Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America's Illegal