The Stated Reason, the Moral Reason, the Real Reason, and the Right Reason

Jacob Sullum on the White House’s “noble” facades:

Last June New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman counted four reasons for the war: the stated reason (Saddam had WMDs and might give them to terrorists for an attack on the U.S.); the moral reason (saving Iraqis and their neighbors from a brutal, murderous tyranny); the real reason (after 9/11, the U.S. had to smack a Muslim country around to show it meant business); and the right reason (defusing the anger that leads to terrorism by transforming Iraq into a model of liberal democracy).

It seems to me the stated reason for war should be the same as the real reason, so the American people can judge for themselves whether it’s right and moral. Distracted by images of nuke-wielding Islamic fanatics, they never really had that opportunity.

Read the whole thing.

I’ve long admired Sullum’s reporting on legal issues, and though my take on Israel is rather different from his (but also see this and this), he has been a consistent critic of Bush’s Iraq policy. Find his archives here.