Former Head of Israeli Nuclear Commission: Iran Is At Least 10 Years Away From a Nuke

The former head of Israel’s Atomic Energy Commission believes Iran is more than a decade away from a nuclear weapon and that the Islamic Republic may not even want “the bomb,” according to the Israeli newspaper Yediot Ahronoth (Ynet news).

An insider in Israel’s nuclear program believes that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is employing needless fearmongering when it comes to Iran’s atomic aspirations, in order to further his own political aims.

Brigadier General (res.) Uzi Eilam, who for a decade headed the Israel Atomic Energy Commission, does not believe that Tehran is even close to having a bomb, if that is even what it really aspires to.

“The Iranian nuclear program will only be operational in another 10 years,” declares Eilam, a senior official in Israel’s atomic program. “Even so, I am not sure that Iran wants the bomb.”

As far as Eilam’s credibility on the issue, Ynet explains that he “comes from the heart of Israel’s secret security mechanisms, having served in senior roles in the defense establishment that culminated in a decade as the head of the atomic agencyBefore his decade heading the Atomic Energy Commission, he was head of the IDF’s Administration for the Development of Weapons and Technological Infrastructure…”

This is not only a rebuke of Netanyahu’s hardline rhetoric on Iran and its nuclear program, but a corrective to the nearly sacrosanct political dogma in the U.S. that Iran is on the verge of deployable nukes. It’s hard to find anyone – from talking-point-reciting politicians to cable news talking heads and supposedly respectable journalists – that fails to refer to the “Iranian nuclear weapons weapons program” or Iran’s “unrelenting pursuit of nuclear weapons.”

This, despite Iran’s cooperation and compliance in unprecedented negotiations with world powers that aim to partially retard and comprehensively limit their civilian nuclear program. Eilam’s heresy isn’t the first Israeli official of prominence to push back on the Netanyahu government’s Iran policy, which at this point amounts to denying Iran’s right under the NPT to develop any nuclear power for civilian use.

Eilam’s comments also coincide with the current consensus in the U.S. intelligence community on Iran’s nuclear program, that it is not intended to develop weapons.

So why does virtually every politician and commentator, left and right, continue to propagate this falsehood?

15 thoughts on “Former Head of Israeli Nuclear Commission: Iran Is At Least 10 Years Away From a Nuke”

  1. "So why does virtually every politician and commentator, left and right, continue to propagate this falsehood?"

    Because they have sold out to the military-industrial and AIPAC lobbies that require enemies for their continued existence. Most things that seem otherwise inexplicable come down to wealth, who has it, and who is willing to sell their soul to get it.

  2. Wonder if Uzi Eilam would dare utter those statements in front of a live audience…..say on Fox News….Nah.

  3. 10 years from one Nuke? Since 1980 most MSM outlets have put Iran from 1 year to 18 monthes from a working nuke, One would still need capable Intercontinental ballistic missiles. Iran and nukes are a charade.

  4. I­m mak­ing ­over $­1­3k a month working ­part tim­e. I kept hea­ring other p­eople tell me­ how much m­oney they can ma­ke­ online­ so I d­ecide­d to look int­o­ it. Wel­, it was all tru­e and ha­s totally ch­anged­ my life. ­This is­ wha­t I do,

    ??????????????? W­­­W­­W.S­­L­­­A­J­­O­­­B­­S­­.C­­­O­M

  5. I­m mak­ing ­over $­1­3k a month working ­part tim­e. I kept hea­ring other p­eople tell me­ how much m­oney they can ma­ke­ online­ so I d­ecide­d to look int­o­ it. Wel­, it was all tru­e and ha­s totally ch­anged­ my life. ­This is­ wha­t I do,

    ??????????????? W­­­W­­W.S­­L­­­A­­M­J­­O­­­B­­S­­.C­­­O­M

  6. nuclear program, the purpose of each country is to defend the country, to avoid the invasion of their weapons to protect their autonomy, diplomatic struggles are important political and evaluation decisions are all or no? I hope the war will not happen.

  7. Oh for f*cks sake! How many more years are we going to have to listen to the "Iran is 1 month, 16 months, 3 years, 5 years, 10 years away" from a nuke? Why do people STILL fall for this crap?

    1. You left out 'weeks' the last time Bibi regurgitate is famous line, he said "Iran is weeks away from whipping up a nuclear bomb."

    2. When you have a paying audience that can be stampeded into whipping out the check book every other day, hysterical ranting and raving is the expected tactic.

  8. National Council of Resistance of Iran, a broad coalition of democratic Iranian organizations, groups, and personalities, was founded in 1981 in Tehran, Iran on the initiative of Massoud Rajavi, the leader of the Iranian Resistance. For more information visit http://www.ncr-iran.org/

  9. I'm really grateful to the author of this post this article by charming and instructive for us live. We actually admire your effort. Maintain the nice work.

Comments are closed.