Netanyahu Uses ‘J14’ Protests to Steal More of Palestine — and Israelis Let Him

This was written two weeks ago and sent to hundreds of American newspapers — only one of which said they’d run it. We never herd back from them after embargoing this piece for days. It’s not quite timely anymore, but these were my views on the “J14” protest movement in Israel, and the analysis still holds, though the protests have died down and will likely now take — conveniently? — a back seat to recent security issues.

Responding to the hundreds of thousands of protesters in Israel’s streets demanding affordable housing, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government has not responded with the opening of land within Israel for more development, but a massive expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank.

Israel’s “J14” protests have been compared to the huge demonstrations of the “Arab Spring” that led to the ousting of two dictators and the undermining of several more. But though J14 is supposed to be about “social justice,” it is of the type that most Israelis consider within the pale: food and housing prices, entitlements, and relations between the several Jewish ethnic groups that reside in the country. The occupation of Palestine is beyond it, and is essentially absent from the discussion.

The cost of Israeli housing is due to overly strict regulation and the hoarding of land by the state land trust, paired with a lackluster economy that has never provided robust wages for workers, especially those belonging to the non-European Jewish castes. The solution has not been to liberalize the housing industry and shake up the moribund economy, but to use the protests as a pretext for further settlement expansion on Palestinian land. The Interior Ministry is expected to approve some 4,300 units of housing in the West Bank for Israeli Jews.

The protests have allowed the state to dramatically ramp up the “acceptable” number of these Jews-only homes on land stolen from Palestinians. Just this past March the US weakly criticized a plan to build a mere 500 settlement apartments.

On the surface, it could seem that this would indeed bring down the cost of housing in Israel, even if you don’t care about legitimate Palestinian grievances. But Israel spends more than half a billion US dollars every year on maintaining and protecting this occupation and making sure Arab anger persists for many more years. In light of the two- to three-billion dollars in aid Israel receives from the United States each year, one could come to the not-rash conclusion that Americans fund this occupation.

Palestinian activists are rightly ho-hum about the movement. Electronic Intifadah’s Ali Abuminah yawns on his Twitter account at the lack of J14 profundity as another writer on the site less-snarkily questions the movement’s radical intentions.

“If Israel announced cheese price hike instead of 1000s more Jim Crow homes on stolen land, Israelis might protest,” Abuminah tweeted, referring to recent outrage over the price of cottage cheese.

Israeli columnist Didi Reider thinks J14 challenges something “deeper” than the occupation — the “principle of separation” itself. But even Reider’s account doesn’t show a willingness of Israelis to apply the alleged undermining of this “principle” outside of the 1967 borders to actual Palestinians living under occupation, instead of just grudgingly accepting that Palestinians with Israeli nationality cards should probably be treated a bit more equally.

The J14 movement could have been used to bring about radical social change in not just Israel’s regimented, top-down economy, but also in the relations between all the individuals who live in Palestine. Instead, it seems Israelis are just fine hitting a perennial pressure-valve used by Israel’s ruling class — taking another bite out of the hide of the long-suffering and marginalized Palestinian.

9 thoughts on “Netanyahu Uses ‘J14’ Protests to Steal More of Palestine — and Israelis Let Him”

  1. Nothing screams APARTHEID like Israeli disenfranchising of Palestinians. Bibi says, "gits back to your reservations Palestinian vermin!" Which might be just dandy IF, Palestinians had anything at all. You know, that hadn't already been ganked by the Israelis.

  2. I'm glad that someone with clout is saying exactly what I've been saying for years now. The Israeli government commits atrocities with the full blessing of its citizenship, the ones that put them in office to begin with. Also, let the record show that administrations on both sides of the political spectrum – right and left – commit crimes against the Palestinians and other nations. This is not a phenomenon reserved for the right wing. Of course, the lefties get upset when I point this out and immediately go on attack mode because how dare anybody point to their hypocrisy? So, the bottom line is that they're all the same, government, citizens, right, left, up, down. And those of you who feel strongly compelled to correct me and chastise me for generalizing can bite my ass.

  3. Yes, Israelis would rather someone else take the hit as would most people. If the government really wanted to punish its people, it would implement market fundamentalism. The real problem in the end is that this is an apartheid regime where one group has some kind of say and everyone else has no say at all and can be made to sacrifice when the group with some say is unhappy with what the ruling elite is implementing.

  4. thedissenter is 100 persent right very few there think different from the govenment to the people.They are conplaining when the Palistnians are living in ten times worse condition.They will be satified when they take even more from Palistine to their benifite.All with military money and weapons from the US along with there VETO power in the UN.The citizens of America is were that money is comingf from to kill and stell from already poor people.American citizens need mass protests against Israel getting there money well commiting war crimes ands crimes against humanity.And thats just the start but western citizens that see there countrys comiting crimes against humanity need to stand up or are we much better.The Arabs stood up to there militarys and in the American civil war 750 tousand people died.Freedom is as imortant as life thats whay troughout history millions have died willingly for it.The weorld weill awake.

  5. hoarding of land by the state land trust,' Interesting considering these same fools feel they are smarter than the people who suffered during the holocaust in that they collect the money can then spend it on what they "Land Hoarders" feel is more important to who? Wh put the Land Hoarders in charge or are they the same as the money changers at the Temple that Jesus took so much objection to.

  6. Some Scientists claim that hydrogen, because it is so plentiful, is the basic building block of the universe. I dispute that. I say there is more stupidity than hydrogen, and that is the basic building block of the universe.
    Frank Zappa

    just look at the above posts . YOU WERE RIGHT FRANK !!

  7. I think this is among the most vital information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is wonderful, the articles is really nice. Good job, cheers!

Comments are closed.