John V. Walsh: The Rule for Respectable Commentary

There is a simple rule that is followed scrupulously by most U.S. commentators of every stripe on world affairs and war.

This rule allows strong criticism of the US But major official adversaries of the US, Iran, Russia and China, must never, ever be presented as better than the US in any significant way. The US may be depicted as equally bad (or better) than these enemies, but never worse.

The Rule.

  • Major Adversaries: Never better than the US
  • US (and the rest of West): Never worse than the Major Adversaries

Of course this is a recipe for demonization and war. In essence the US must be presented at worst as the lesser evil.

That is the Rule for Respectable Commentary.

Who or what is the enforcer? I have written to other writers who admit that they avoid speaking well of Major Adversaries even when it is warranted. They know that they will come under attack and their credibility will be questioned. They know that editors, ever conscious of their credibility (as they should be) and of their donors (as they should not be) will turn down the writing of one who violates The Rule for Respectable Commentary, hereafter known as The Rule.

So it is censorship that enforces The Rule, but largely self-censorship of the very kind which runs rampant in the Main Stream Media and which is so often bemoaned in the alternative press. "We have met the enemy and they are us."

This of course is a silly rule when you think about it. The world is a complex place and it would be foolish to be regard major powers like Russia, China and Iran as lacking any achievements in any area that eclipse those of the US When confronted by overwhelming evidence of a considerable achievement by a Major Adversary, the Rule has a corollary which counsels silence. Avoid the subject. If you do not have anything bad to say, then do not say anything. Of course this leads to lack of perspective and to half-truths. And half-truths are full lies, as an Israeli expat reminds me constantly.

Let us take China as an example. There are many things to admire about China, if we speak frankly. It administered the most devastating blow to colonialism when it broke free of Western and Japanese domination after suffering colonial devastation of the most cruel sort. (If one does not know about the Opium Wars and the way China was turned into a nation of addicts, impoverished by merciless indemnities imposed by the West, then take a look at this brief account. It is free.)

Not only that, but China has pulled hundreds of millions out of poverty, 600 million plus, according to the UN. That is a staggering achievement, unparalleled in world history. China has a long history of nonaggression overseas and even though it is the world’s number one economy based on Purchasing Power Parity according the IMF, it still has no overseas military bases. Even Henry Kissinger in his book On China, has to admit that China has no tradition of overseas conquests. When China was the world’s number one power, including maritime power, and sailed a vast fleet to Africa almost a century before Columbus set sail, it did not conquer, did not enslave. That is quite a different story from the conquering imperial West. (I just broke the Rule in that paragraph!)

If one mentions such accomplishments too prominently, one is called a "China lover" or, in a return to good old fashioned anti-Communism, a lover of the CCP (Chinese Communist Party). I have had the honor of such opprobrium.

And here I must note the almost irrational animus toward China amongst certain progressives. It was all too evident in the recent demonstrations in Hong Kong funded by the National Endowment for Democracy, with highly manipulable high school students in the "lead" and with other leaders meeting with Joe Biden. Such elements were dismissed as marginal even as the neo-Nazi elements that led the Maidan revolt were dismissed as "marginal" when their presence became undeniable. For these progressives, the evils of China and the US are the same which keeps them comfortably within the confines of The Rule. (These worthies have a blind spot not just for the strengths of China but also for those of the US There is a lot of blindness in this vision.)

Why this animus? It seems that progressives of a certain age feel that China "betrayed the world revolution." (Unfortunately for these armchair revolutionaries, the Chinese people had very different goals for the revolution they made.) Others see no value in defeating colonialism and poverty but regard only the struggle for Western democracy worthwhile, even as they bemoan the shallowness or the downright fraudulence of such democracy. In any event the animus helps them keep to The Rule.

As I have written elsewhere, there is a simple antidote to all this. Take a few moments on a daily basis and look at the headlines of China Daily,, and even Iran’s PressTV. If the headlines strike your fancy, read on. And compare what you read there, including the perspective and narrative, with what you encounter in the NYT, NPR, etc. Make up your own mind.

And if you write on world affairs whether books or letters to the editor, then for the sake of truth and peace, it is time to Break The Rule – into a thousand pieces.

John V. Walsh can be reached at john.endwar@gmail .com.

25 thoughts on “John V. Walsh: The Rule for Respectable Commentary”

  1. What an accurate description of the Western propaganda industry. Few years ago, I challenged an award winning Australian journalist for producing 3 different stories that contradicted each other on the same event a year apart. I pressured him by challenging him openly, and made a series of complaints to The Ages (One of the Fairfax newspapers where he worked as a China correspondent at the time), Media Watch and the Australia Press Council, and received his replies. I published the content of his emails and proved that he is guilty of dodgy journalism. However, he was protected by his editor, The Media Watch and the Australia Press Council. That incident not only did not affect his career in the industry, he has been promoted and become one of the Fairfax editor recently. This is the link to the story:

  2. Forget about it. Things are going to get a lot worse before they get better. Better to find another country you like and move.

  3. Outstandingly incisive, as usual from Walsh. And couldn't agree more with the recommendation at the end. Recommendations to read as widely as possible and make up one's own mind indicate openness and truthfulness. What corporate media outlet encourages us to also read international, non-western press?

  4. And also, when you read "Russia", just read "Putin" in it's place and you will be right in line with the propagandists and their demonization campaign.
    Such shallow b.s. seems to be all it takes. So Juan's right, nothing much is going to change.

  5. A Bundesliga promises loads of action 2010, with three teams perfect for competing for any prize. Germany's formidable showing along at the 2006 Community Cup helped help league while in the eyes for many spectators, and it have become extra competitive due to this fact. <a href="” target=”_blank”>

  6. Media – This part lets you view your whole media that has been inputted or merged into your tree. Sources – that is the realm that lists all sources you've gotten used to finish your tree so far and the place you found these sources. You can also create an incredible genealogy book and have it professionally printed. Internet Search – this is the part you use to search, view and print all of the data in Ancestry or other sites and the ability to merge the knowledge into your family tree.

  7. You don't need to choose a dentist that doesn't provide this as a result of then you may be scrambling, when someone in your family is in pain to locate a new dentist that does provide it.

  8. There are also garden areas which might be comprised of settings which are very lovely and specifically designed for Family Portraits. In case you are also on the lookout for children photographers to cowl some Family Portraits for you then you are assured to access them on this location. Try to find a location that's in between where most relations could be travelling.

  9. Create an American Health Profit Change and a Small Business Well being Options Program (STORE) Alternate for people and small companies and provide oversight of health plans with regard to the brand new insurance coverage market regulations, client protections, rate evaluations, solvency, reserve fund requirements, premium taxes, and to define score areas.

  10. Through the setup process, members of the family might also just enter their Apple ID or password to altogether keep away from sending and accepting invitations. And at last, you will be in only one family group at a time. You're additionally only allowed to modify to a distinct family group twice per yr.

  11. Word of love and appreciation and greeting fulfillment and private
    Greeting fill all the meanings of brotherhood and friendship
    Greetings from the Heart to Heart
    Thank you with all my heart
    ????? ????
    and welcom to d great blog for cooking games m^p

  12. Good job. This is very nice post. I like your post. Its fantastic. Thanks a lot for share and that's my request please share me more post in future. .This is a very beautiful gym flooring and I would recommend you to use Stable mats for this beast.

  13. A Bundesliga promises loads of action 2010, with three teams perfect for competing for any prize. Germany's formidable showing along at the 2006 Community Cup helped help league while in the eyes for many spectators, and it have become extra competitive due to this fact.

Comments are closed.