‘The Boys Who Said No!’: New Documentary About War Resisters

Evil is participatory, says interviewee David Harris at the beginning of a documentary in progress about Vietnam-era draft resisters, The Boys Who Said No!

Evil continuing depends on people joining in, and the first step to stopping it, he continues, is withdrawing your own participation. So Harris said no to the Vietnam-era draft, and went to jail for it.

The Boys Who Said No!

The Boys Who Said No! is set during the late 1960s and early 70s, when thousands resisted conscription at the risk of federal prison. Unlike those who evaded the draft by fleeing to Canada, getting various deferments, or resorting to violent protest, the subjects of this film chose civil disobedience.

It was a costly decision.

An estimated 500,000 young men evaded or refused to cooperate with the draft, and 3,250 went to prison for their beliefs, the largest mass incarceration of war resisters in U.S. history. The film tackles this broad narrative mostly through the story of David Harris (who spent three years in Federal prison for refusing to be drafted, and for encouraging others to do the same) and his wife, folksinger Joan Baez. Interviews with many other draft resisters round out the narrative.

As part of understanding the Vietnam era, the film also reviews the history of the draft, and opposition to previous drafts, and the Vietnam war. Resistance to the war is tied into the larger civil rights movement, two sides of the same coin in opposing unjust actions by the government, with the inclusion of the Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr. visiting Joan Baez and those jailed for blocking the Oakland Draft Board in 1967.

How Do You Say “Vietnam” in Arabic? Iraq

To a younger audience, the film is perhaps a bit funny, guys with weird hair and unhip clothing burning whatever draft cards were. For a cynical generation, it is as easy to dismiss the value of individual action as it is wrong to do so. Indeed, the actions of one person alone can amount to little. But as an interviewee says, you never know who’s watching. The Boys Who Said No! illustrates how one can become two, two can become ten, and over time they together remind you all that sand on the beach was once a rock.

The Boys Who Said No! thus resonates strongly today.

It offers an answer to the question of what courage is in a modern world: not only choosing the harder right over the easier wrong, but being willing to pay the price for acting on conscience, for a good bigger than oneself. And in that definition, the actions of men like David Harris and the thousands who joined him in refusing the draft, become clearer. The path they put themselves on leads in a straight line through whistleblowers Ellsberg (Pentagon Papers), Drake and Binney (NSA), Manning and Assange (Iraq War), Kiriakou and Sterling (CIA), and Snowden.

Acts of conscience never go out of fashion, and a country never has enough examples. That’s what makes a film like The Boys Who Said No! more than historical document.

To many today the war in Vietnam seems as old as the battles at Gettysburg and Antietam. But think about this: Vietnam was a war started on false pretenses (US ships attacked in Gulf of Tonkin, Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq), built on deeply flawed fear (Communism will overtake Southeast Asia, a caliphate will engulf the Middle East), a faux-threat to the United States/Homeland (Communists on the beaches of California, Islamic terrorists in your town) and the strategy of extraordinary means spent for limited ends. Very, very similar comparisons apply to America’s war in Central America during the 1980s.

And before you dismiss that by saying the struggle against Islamic terror is “different,” remember this: history shows those who resisted the war in Vietnam, and that in Central America, turned out to be right.

The Boys Who Said No! is currently in production, but in need of additional funding for completion. Take a look at a 17 minute excerpt, and visit the project’s website, Facebook, or Indiegogo page if you wish to contribute.

A Bit More

The Boys Who Said No! was directed is Judith Ehrlich, who won an Academy Award nomination for The Most Dangerous Man in America: Daniel Ellsberg and the Pentagon Papers. The producer is Christopher C. Jones, who at age 17 refused to register for the draft, was arrested and served nine months in federal prison. As the documentary is not complete, my comments above are based on previews and clips I have seen.

The film takes its title from a 1960s poster showing Joan Baez’ sisters sitting on a couch with the caption “Girls say yes to boys who say no.”


Peter Van Buren blew the whistle on State Department waste and mismanagement during Iraqi reconstruction in his first book, We Meant Well: How I Helped Lose the Battle for the Hearts and Minds of the Iraqi People. His latest book is Ghosts of Tom Joad: A Story of the #99 Percent. Reprinted from the his blog with permission.

10 thoughts on “‘The Boys Who Said No!’: New Documentary About War Resisters”

  1. This video took me on a trip down memory lane. My anti-war life started during Vietnam and I still hate war today. When will we ever learn?

    1. probably about the same amount more than it does to defend a witch rather than going along burning ’em … especially since ‘we’ embrace overwhelming force over ‘fair fights.’

      1. I dont understand your point at all – most people have no beef with foreigners they’d end up killing if the joined the military

        1. ‘most…have no beef with [who] they’d end up killing if the joined’
          S’pect that’s true of the military, but it could be that it also applies to joining witch hunt team, or otherwise going along. That the target doesn’t stand a chance, that there is pressure to hit it, and that there’s thus more pressure to hit it than to refuse (independently of whether individuals involved really hate it) … is kinda my sense of it.

          I was USN from ’98-’04, and I did ask myself very early why it was that I didn’t feel like I’d get hanged just for going along, even just dignifying it, in ’02-’03. Obvious answer: trials of ‘villains’ is kind of our schtick. So there was zero risk to going along for me, but it’s clearly a pain to resist. And I knew that instinctively enough that I was lucky to have formulated the question at all. Sorry if I can’t explain better than that, and maybe I shouldn’t speak for everyone…

  2. from dave eberhardt (Baltimore 4)- sounds great- can’t wait- see also the documentary “Hit and Stay” re draft board actions- Betty Medsger’s “The Burglary” google Transform Now Plowshares and Code Pink for those still saying no. My For All the Saints a 120 page voyage into the heart of the 60’s. in final editing.

    After 21 months in federal prison at Lewisburg for pouring blood on
    draft files to protest the Vietnam War with Father Philip Berrigan in 1967, and a career aiding prisoners at the Baltimore City Jail; a child of the 60’s offers a poetic exploration of non- violence and a life spent in revolutionary movements….over 30 years in and out of prison.

  3. Many right wingers supported the war in Nam and condemned those who resisted the draft. Interestingly, thousands of Israelis and Russians immigrated illegally into the USA by way of NYC in order to avoid the draft in those countries. Yet those same critics have never criticized them for doing so.

  4. my book just out re Fr Berrigan and the peace movement-5/20/17
    “For all the Saints”- david eberhardt (baltimore 4 9 we poured blood on draft files)

Comments are closed.