"When you’re wounded and left on Afghanistan’s plains, and the women come out to cut up what remains, jest roll to your rifle and blow out your brains and go to your gawd like a soldier." ~ Kipling
English poet Rudyard Kipling’s spirit may breathe a sigh of relief now that President Joe Biden has decided to end the latest March of Folly into Afghanistan. Kipling immortalized the phrase "White Man’s Burden" used as an excuse for European-American imperialism. (And Barbara Tuchman’s, March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam, published in 1984, is a well worth reading again.)
There can be many a slip between cup and lip but, for the nonce, it does seem as though the Western White (U.S. and NATO troops) will be out of Afghanistan by Sept. 11 – leaving widespread rubble for which the countries who sent them there will be responsible, yet miserly in helping repair.
Artificial ‘Light At the End of the Tunnel’
In Afghanistan, as was the case with the war in Vietnam, US generals and courtier pundits lied through their teeth. They continually lied about the progress they were making, as Craig Whitlock makes clear in excruciating detail in his Dec. 2019 Washington Post report The Afghanistan Papers A secret history of the war: At war with the truth.
You did not have to go through the crucible of Vietnam – or wait for honest reporting from the very few like Whitlock – to discern how Americans, including some presidents, were being misled on Afghanistan. The experience of Vietnam, though, did throw rather clear deja-vu light on this latest folly and its spurious justifications. With a modicum of experience in media analysis, it was not difficult to penetrate the deceit and piece together what was really going on.
You Can Do It Without Spies?
I am almost amused thinking back on how President Reagan’s CIA Director, Bill Casey, was astonished to learn that over 80 percent of intelligence analysis was based on open sources. When today’s journalists ask the agency’s PR unit about me, the standard answer is that, since I no longer have access to classified reporting, I cannot possibly know what is going on.
But at a time when Gen. David Petraeus prevented my former analyst colleagues from having input into decisions on the relative merits of "surging" tens of thousands more troops into Afghanistan, I did not need intelligence from sleuths, surveillance, spies, or satellites to warn President Obama 12 years ago that:
"Gallons of blood are likely to be poured unnecessarily in the mountains and valleys of Afghanistan – probably over the next decade or longer."
(See: Welcome to Vietnam, Mr. President, March 28, 2009)
Back to Kipling
Kipling himself came to recognize the dangers – and ultimate folly – of imperialism. He wrote:
It is not wise for the Christian white
To hustle the Asian brown;
For the Christian riles
And the Asian smiles
And weareth the Christian down.
At the end of the fight
Lies a tombstone white
With the name of the late deceased;
And the epitaph drear,
A fool lies here,
Who tried to hustle the East.
When Kipling’s only son John was killed in battle in France in 1915, Kipling saw things still more differently. He wrote:
"If any question why we died, tell them, because our fathers lied."
Sadly, Kipling’s aphorism applies as aptly to the roughly 2,400 US and 1,200 "coalition" troops killed in the latest March of Folly into Afghanistan – not to mention many times as many Afghans.
Still more sadly, although President Joe Biden personally knows, all too well, the generals who lied, he could not hold them accountable even if he had the courage to try. MICIMATT (the Military-Industrial-Congressional-Intelligence-Media-Academia-Think-Tank) complex is in charge.
Ray McGovern works with Tell the Word, a publishing arm of the ecumenical Church of the Saviour in inner-city Washington. His 27-year career as a CIA analyst includes serving as Chief of the Soviet Foreign Policy Branch and preparer/briefer of the President’s Daily Brief. He is co-founder of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS).
2 thoughts on “Afghanistan: ‘White Man’s Burden’ Lifted?”
Nobody is leaving anywhere. Even if “official” numbers say otherwise, there will still be CIA, Xe mercenaries, all the folks needed to keep the puppet of the day in power, and all the folks needed to protect and process the opium poppies for the CIA’s global heroin distribution network. The gullible will believe it is over and the profits will continue to flow to the same blood-soaked bank accounts that have benefited for 2 decades now.
Queen Victoria must not have like Kipling anymore than she liked Gladstone (one of the PM’s of the UK in her time) . They were both against empire building. My family is originally from India so some of my ancestors lived in India under British rule. It is too bad neither Kipling nor Gladstone could convince Queen Victoria to abandon the empire and leave the rest of the world alone.
Comments are closed.