The Danger of Precedents

The second installment of the Washington Post‘s investigation into the Obama administration’s drone war is as important as the first, Greg Miller’s piece which revealed the “disposition matrix,” and which I discussed here. But this article, written by Karen DeYoung, descends into a character piece on John Brennan, Obama’s counter-terrorism adviser who spearheads the targeting process of the drone wars. Brennan is presented towards the end as deeply concerned with transparency and the ethical and legal implications of the drone wars:

One official said that “for a guy whose reputation is focused on how tough he is on counterterrorism,” Brennan is “more focused than anybody in the government on the legal, ethical and transparency questions associated with all this.” By drawing so much decision-making directly into his own office, said another, he has “forced a much better process at the CIA and the Defense Department.”

Clearly there are some problems with this interpretation, and we know what they are. But DeYoung sets readers up for a powerful concluding thought:

Even if Obama is reelected, Brennan may not stay for another term. That means someone else is likely to be interpreting his playbook.

“Do I want this system to last forever?” a senior official said. “No. Do I think it’s the best system for now? Yes.”

“What is scary,” he concluded, “is the apparatus set up without John to run it.”

So leaving aside the characterization of team Brennan-Obama as ethically-minded warriors inclined towards transparency, it is quite easy to envision a future administration which is far less ethical, far less transparent, and far more brutal in their execution of the drone war apparatus that they set up. This has been a common question from the beginning: what kind of precedent has the Obama administration set, and how will a future Luca Brasi in a future presidential administration use these powers to kill?

50 thoughts on “The Danger of Precedents”

  1. The armed robber caught by police was especially concerned with the ethical and legal implications of the bank operation. Particularly, since a guard and a teller were dead, he was especially interested in the criminal penalties that could be exacted by a vicious, unpredictable legal system. And since he might not be in charge of the gang for a while, he was concerned that his friend who now runs the operation would make similar errors, endangering the survival of his organization.

  2. "So leaving aside the characterization of team Brennan-Obama as ethically-minded warriors inclined towards transparency"

    It's unreal, instead of rule of law we are sold how ethical and educated these guys are. But they read great philosophers, and are deeply familiar with religious traditions and … they are like college professors combined with monks.

    AS IF …. AS IF … the cumulation of the western tradition, as flawed as it is, was benign (or not so benign) dictatorship and philosopher kings, rather than the rule of law and protection of individual rights. They drop more great works names than a Great Books Club and more references to morals than Bill Bennet. Fricken Philosopher Kings. Murdering philsospher dictators.

  3. I wonder how long before a drone comes to visit THEM…..!!!!! Sent by ……………??????????? Clues
    here……………?????

    "(The Mother of All Updates 7/22 – Holy Toledo! Thanks to intrepid readers I have been provided an Al-Jazeera op-ed story that says that Omar Suleiman died in Cleveland, Ohio on July 19, 2012 and goes farther in describing the Al-Libi case, to wit:

    Starting quote:

    Ibn al-Sheikh al-Libi (Ali Mohammed al-Fakheri) is the second most infamous case under Suleiman. He was a Libyan citizen reportedly captured and interrogated by the CIA, the EGIA, and other security services. The George W Bush administration cited the false information al-Libi gave under torture by Egyptian authorities as evidence of the link between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda in the months preceding the 2003 US invasion of Iraq.

    When the information was proven to be false, it was a source of great personal embarrassment to Suleiman. Not only had he allegedly tortured an Arab citizen to extract information for the CIA, but he also inadvertently provided justification to the Bush administration for the invasion of Iraq. This is an addition to the apparent incompetence in assessing the information extracted under torture. al-Libi was handed over to the Gaddafi regime in Libya, which Suleiman visited in May 2009. By the time Suleiman’s plane left Libya, al-Libi had allegedly “committed suicide”, the Gaddafi regime announced.

    “”This is the bloody joke,” a former member of the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group, who was imprisoned with al-Libi in Tripoli’s notorious Abu Salim prison, told me in an interview. “Al-Libi is a religious man. He would never do that. He was killed by the Libyan Internal Security Services as a favour to Suleiman.&rdquo ;http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2012/07/2012720132344865981.html"

    http://www.saltlaw.org/blog/2012/07/19/targeted-k

  4. They basically ask the public to trust their words – “transparency, ethical, priest-like, with moral rectitude” – and not judge their actions – pathological secrecy, indiscriminate killers, narcissistic god complex. Even more astounding, people buy it. They buy it because the defer to the authority.

  5. Re: "So leaving aside the characterization of team Brennan-Obama as ethically-minded warriors inclined towards transparency"

    So who makes the determination that Brennan and Obama are ethically-minded and inclined towards transparency? Brennan and Obama?

    Miller and DeYoung only know what they tell them…

  6. The armed robber caught by police was especially concerned with the ethical and legal implications of the bank operation. Particularly, since a guard and a teller were dead, he was especially interested in the criminal penalties that could be exacted by a vicious, unpredictable legal system. And since he might not be in charge of the gang for a while, he was concerned that his friend who now runs the operation would make similar errors, endangering the survival of his organization.

    1. this is remarkable share, i tried to read all the content and i must say that it is best written..
      thanks for sharing with us, the aabove view can be change by just putting some narrow obligation

  7. The armed robber caught by police was especially concerned with the ethical and legal implications of the bank operation. Particularly, since a guard and a teller were dead, he was especially interested in the criminal penalties that could be exacted by a vicious, unpredictable legal system. And since he might not be in charge of the gang for a while, he was concerned that his friend who now runs the operation would make similar errors, endangering the survival of his organization.
    φωτιστικα

  8. Ibn al-Sheikh al-Libi (Ali Mohammed al-Fakheri) is the second most infamous case under Suleiman. He was a Libyan citizen reportedly captured and interrogated by the CIA, the EGIA, and other security services. The George W Bush administration cited the false information al-Libi gave under torture by Egyptian authorities as evidence of the link between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda in the months preceding the 2003 US invasion of Iraq. sewage cleanup

  9. The armed robber caught by police was especially concerned with the ethical and legal implications of the bank operation. Particularly, since a guard and a teller were dead, he was especially interested in the criminal penalties that could be exacted by a vicious, unpredictable legal system. And since he might not be in charge of the gang for a while, he was concerned that his friend who now runs the operation would make similar errors, endangering the survival of his organization.

  10. Everybody likes entertainment ,some entertain themselves by listening or singing music
    others like to playing game,and bubble trouble is very tricky, you have to use the directions key to go here and there and you can shoot with the help of space key.

  11. I do not think there are people who agree with the act of murder that occurred in the country of Iran. In my opinion, the power of which is owned by the state should be able to put to good use to help other countries in need.

  12. Un autre développement de cette idée sont les chèques cadeaux génériques qui peuvent être servis dans des endroits différents. Panier cela souvent. Vous pouvez acheter des chèques cadeaux à n'importe quel magasin et la personne qui reçoit le chèque pourrait l'échanger dans n'importe quelle pharmacie.
    220 license

  13. Një problem i zakonshëm me të cilat përballen një kompani që bën hulumtimin e tregut është në qoftë se ata nuk përgjigjen si ata të drejtuar të paditurit të injorojnë. Nëse ju doni për të kryer hulumtime të tregut, të jetë i sinqertë në lidhje me rezultatet dhe të bëjë diçka në lidhje me rezultatet e kërkimit.
    The Yoga of Love

  14. L'étude de marché est un outil de marketing très puissant pour toute entreprise. Essentiellement, vous demandez des clients potentiels ou des clients existants sur un certain nombre de choses. Les réponses à ces questions sont ensuite utilisées pour formuler la direction de votre entreprise.
    Dallas AC Repair

  15. Intention of a party to fight it should be undone. There are many people who know nothing about what they can feel when there is a war and there are many people who died.

  16. War will only make more people be able to live in peace. You can find many other better solution than to feel the danger of war on the population in your country.wedding tiaras uk

  17. Before you search the information in the internet, you need to think what your need for the holiday is. Do you want budget holiday? Or do you want holiday with high standard of accommodation? Per the information provided, you can then select and use the camping holiday smartly.

  18. Perhaps the Obama administration is trying to cover its tracks. More likely, however, is that in a similar way to how Obama was scrambling to write a legal code to govern his illegal drone wars in case Republican Mitt Romney was elected in 2012, this is an attempt to codify and institutionalize the targeted assassination of American citizens.

  19. This sort of behavior from a business executive sets a dangerous precedent,” said Mitt Romney, when a voter asked him what he thought of Yuanqing's act of generosity. “This sort of thing goes against the grain of what we expect from our executives.

  20. You are every reason, every hope, and every dream I've ever had, and no matter what happens to us in the future, everyday we are together is the greatest day of my life. I will always be yours.

Comments are closed.