Lies & Distortions From the Pentagon’s Afghanistan Press Conference

George Little, Pentagon Press Secretary and Captain John Kirby, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Media Operations spoke to reporters yesterday about the ruckus unleashed in Afghanistan after the U.S. military burned Muslim holy books. Massive protests have taken place, even spreading over into Pakistan, against the foreign occupiers for “dishonoring the Koran…disrespecting our dead and killing our children.” The chaos led NATO to abruptly pull all its staff from the Afghanistan’s government ministries on Saturday after a vengeful Afghan shot a U.S. colonel and major inside the ministry, and U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan Ryan Crocker pleaded not to pull out early just because of the unrest.

I just wanted to note two quick things about the Pentagon’s statement’s yesterday.

GEORGE LITTLE: Tragically, many in Afghanistan have been killed or wounded as a result of violence there.  Extremists have killed four Americans, including two officers within the confines of the Afghan Interior Ministry.  These are tough losses, and they demonstrate that we will experience challenges in the course of this campaign.

Many Afghans “have been killed or wounded as a result of the violence there.” More accurately, U.S.-supported Afghan security forces have killed and wounded dozens of Afghans who are protesting the abuses of foreign domination. As Glenn Greenwald pointed out:

Meanwhile, the protesters themselves continue to be shot, although mostAmerican media accounts favor sentences like these which whitewash who is doing the killing: “running clashes with the police that claimed the lives of another five Afghan protesters” and “in Nangarhar Province, two Afghans protesting the Koran burning were shot to death outside an American base in Khogyani District” and “protesters angry over the burning of Korans at the largest American base in Afghanistan this week took to the streets in demonstrations in a half-dozen provinces on Wednesday that left at least seven dead and many more injured.” Left at least seven dead: as As’ad AbuKhalil observed, “notice that there is no killer in the phrasing.”

Secondly, Little said the following:

But let me be clear.  First, Secretary Panetta and Chairman Dempsey are fully committed to our strategy in Afghanistan.  They believe we have achieved significant progress in reversing the Taliban’s momentum and in developing the Afghan security forces, and they believe that the fundamentals of our strategy remain sound.

…We’re making progress.  We have put the enemy on its heels in many parts of the country.  Doesn’t mean that there isn’t work to be done — there is — but let’s not let the events of the past week steer us away from the reality that we have made significant progress throughout the country.

I won’t run through the catalog of evidence plainly disproving these statements. I’ve done that sufficiently elsewhere. A short excerpt from Michael Hastings’s book The Operators gets the point across:

The United States regularly declares success in Afghanistan, despite mounting evidence to the contrary. A year doesn’t pass without public declarations of progress. In 2001, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld says, “It’s not a quagmire.” In 2003, the commanding general in Afghanistan says that U.S. forces should be down to 4,500 soldiers by the end of the following summer. After that summer, General John P. Abizaid says the Taliban “is increasingly ineffective.” In 2005, the Taliban is “collapsing,” says General Dave Barno. In 2007, we are “prevailing against the effects of prolonged war,” declares Major General Robert Durbin. In 2008, General Dan McNeill claims that “my successor will find an insurgency here, but it is not spreading.” That same year, Defese Secretary Robert Gates assures us we have a “very successful counterinsurgency,” and we won’t need a “larger western footprint” in the country.

This month, Lt. Col. Daniel Davis embarrassed the U.S. leadership in Afghanistan when he wrote a report arguing “Our current military leadership is so distorting the information it releases that the deterioration of the situation and the failing nature of our efforts is shielded from the American public (and Congress), and replaced instead with explicit statements that all is going according to plan.” I guess those criticisms didn’t stick.

44 thoughts on “Lies & Distortions From the Pentagon’s Afghanistan Press Conference”

  1. Pingback: Anonymous
  2. What other comments does one expect from two government lackeys. How long do you think they'd keep their taxpayer salaries and taxpayer funded government pensions if they didn't tow the company line. How do they sleep at night? Are they that delusional or just outright cowards.

  3. Same yesterday's horse lunch as we heard in the late 60's warmed over in the same fashion. They could dust off the old 'making progress' releases and white out/retype the country and enemy names but of course frugality doesn't enter the picture here.

  4. What strategy? All I have seen in the last 5 years is "we are making progress , fragile but reversible."

  5. Lt. Col. Daniel Davis just did right thing, its better to be true rather than distorting information. I hope there will no more lies, but there will always be~ very disappointing.
    Great article.

    Tifa from sucette pour bébé 

  6. Hey, I have been searching for reviews of people who know about this, and after browsing the directories, I came to your write up, and it really is wonderful write up. Too bad I took so much time getting to your blog. Saved you in my bookmarks already. Will come back again. Just keep writing people like me will follow you.

  7. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  8. Amazing post, I like it. It was quite interesting nice work. I appreciate the information you provided is excellent post. Thank you for sharing you do.
    Window Tintin

  9. Thanks for sharing such a useful information. The information provided is very very niche. I was just surfing on internet and found your blog after reading this i realize that i should come here often.

  10. I have to say I am very impressed with the way you efficiently website and your posts are so informative. Thanks a lot for your wonderful work! Here Wonder Know is a comprehensive website that provides all kinds of articles. Just have a look, you may enjoy it!

  11. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  12. ctually Estoy pensando en lo que debería decir en este blog informativo sobre licensing.I quieres saber más tema como este y por eso pide a su compañero operation.Please ayudarme dando algo más de información sobre el mismo, así como en la empresa del Reino Unido son los contadores que familiar para todos.

  13. I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job .

  14. Hi, thank you for sharing this great info. Was just browsing through the net in my office and happened upon your blog. It is really very well written and quit comprehensive in explaining with a very simple language.

Comments are closed.