NY Times Op-Ed: ‘Bomb Syria, Even if It Is Illegal’

I really can’t add much to this…

Screen Shot 2013-08-29 at 9.36.24 AM

Here’s the link.

At least it’s an honest argument. And it’s the same for many people now pining for another U.S. war in the Middle East: “the law” is just some antiquated, idealistic notion that doesn’t apply to states, especially when you’re the most powerful nation on Earth…our might makes it right.

17 thoughts on “NY Times Op-Ed: ‘Bomb Syria, Even if It Is Illegal’”

  1. Positive law is fallible…it doesn’t always coincide with natural law. Thus, the argument that you shouldn’t do something because it is illegal doesn’t hold up since the law can in itself be unjust. So I agree with him on this point. But aggressing against Individuals to fund the war (taxation) and potentially aggressing against non-participants (civilians) is unjust regardless of its “legality”.

  2. Yea but it's NOT HONEST, only the headline is honest, read the last paragraphs:

    "It must either argue that an “illegal but legitimate” intervention is better than doing nothing, or assert that international law has changed — strategies that I call “constructive noncompliance.” In the case of Syria, I vote for the latter.

    Since Russia and China won’t help, Mr. Obama and allied leaders should declare that international law has evolved and that they don’t need Security Council approval to intervene in Syria.

    This would be popular in many quarters, and I believe it’s the right thing to do. But if the American government accepts that the rule of law is the foundation of civilized society, it must be clear that this represents a new legal path."

    So it's going to pretend the laws have changed when they really haven't, just outright defect from the UN entirely, uh am I missing something? It doesn't even argue the laws should be changed by whatever process is in place, but just to assert the law is something else. Imagine Manning: yes sir what I did was illegal under previous laws, but the laws have changed ….

    Oh right, you can't. It's just another variation of: "laws are for the little people". Which come to think of it is all we ever get from the elite anyway, isn't it?

  3. It's worthwhile reading our Thucydides once again. The idea that "might makes right" combined with a culture of charismatic, "celebrity" leaders is a recipe for disaster.

  4. OK, so if the author advocates the notion that "there are moral reasons for [the government} to disregard the law", and the responsible officials are not jailed, then opponents of the war can say "there are moral reasons for disregarding the law on paying taxes to support the government" and not have to go to jail.

  5. Can US war makers be called "Narcissistic Abusers ?" They fit the classic profile.

  6. Obama can not even declare NO fly zone on IsraelME.OPEX declare war on Quran/Muslims but Mursi did not listen.

  7. The United States and the OTAN aren't the world police. We MUST oppose to their new war.

  8. Snowden also seems eerily resigned to the likely consequences of his actions — namely that he may never see his home country again, and that government officials may come for him at any time.

  9. Nearly all the menus are understandable without reading the manual, which is refreshing for a modern piece of digital equipment. This a good light hair oil and conditioner for my hair. If you're like me and do alot of outdoors shooting and don't want to worry about banging up expensive glass, then this is a must-have. Where To Get Milk Thistle Supplements I have noticed a buzzing feeling about 10 minutes after I take my dose. I really enjoyed this book. Also the need for halogen lamps of a specific size seems a bit bogus. I just spray a bit on my damp roots and tousle in before blow drying. Uses Of Milk Thistle Tablets milk thistle Is Milk Thistle Tea Good For The Liver click here…

  10. It's worthwhile reading our Thucydides once again. The idea that "might makes right" combined with a culture of charismatic, "celebrity" leaders is a recipe for disaster.

  11. Word of love and appreciation and greeting fulfillment and private
    Greeting fill all the meanings of brotherhood and friendship
    Greetings from the Heart to Heart
    Thank you with all my heart
    ????? ????
    and welcom to d great blog for cooking games ki

Comments are closed.